STATELESSNESS AS A PRODUCT OF SLIPPERY
STATECRAFT: A GLOBAL GOVERNANCE VIEW OF
CURRENT CAUSES, ACTORS AND DEBATES
ALLISON J PETROZZIELLO *
Statelessness has been described as the result of unintentional gaps between citizenship policies
excluding individuals who move, form relationships and reproduce across international borders.
But what if the rise in statelessness is not a technicality, but a strategy of slippery statecraft meant
to design the citizenry a given state is willing to protect? This paper places statelessness within
the context of neoliberal globalisation and international migration and provides a critical global
governance view of contemporary causes of statelessness, key actors working on it and their
framing of the issue within global governance frameworks. I argue that the dominant framing of
statelessness as a technical issue obviates the politics behind statelessness as slippery statecraft,
leading proposed solutions to fall short. Critical research may help advocates make the case for
inclusion, appealing to broader state interests and networks, without abandoning attendant human
rights obligations.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction........................................................................................................... 136
A Brief History of Statelessness in Global Governance ....................................... 138
Contemporary Causes of Statelessness ................................................................. 140
Global Governance Actors Concerned with Statelessness ................................... 145
UNHCR’s Technical Approach to Ending Statelessness ...................................... 145
Institute on Statelessness and Inclusion’s Human Rights-Based Approach ......... 148
Depoliticising Statelessness to Integrate It in Global Governance Frameworks .. 149
Concluding Remarks: Seeing the state in Statelessness and New
Ways of Seeing ..................................................................................................... 152
INTRODUCTION
With unprecedented numbers of people on the move, stateless populations are
cropping up in new places and for reasons other than displacement by conflict or
state succession. International labour migration and attempts to manage it are
creating what Rhoda Howard-Hassmann and Margaret Walton-Roberts have
called a ‘slippery slope of citizenship’ 1 along which migrants and their children
may find themselves manufactured as the ‘citizen’s Other’ 2 — not only noncitizens, but stateless.
*
1
2
Allison J Petrozziello is a feminist migration researcher and human rights advocate, currently
pursuing a PhD in Global Governance at Wilfrid Laurier University/Balsillie School of
International Affairs in Canada, where she is affiliated with the International Migration
Research Centre.
Rhoda E Howard-Hassmann and Margaret Walton-Roberts, The Human Right to Citizenship:
A Slippery Concept (University of Pennsylvania Press 2015) 5.
Audrey Macklin, ‘Who is the Citizen’s Other? Considering the Heft of Citizenship’ (2007)
8(2) Theoretical Inquiries in Law 333.