Israeli Policies and Practices
Israel’s collective punishment of Palestinians has been denounced numerous
times by the UN, international and local human rights organizations, and
the media. The punitive revocation of permit, curfews, the deliberate
damage to properties, administrative and/or physical closures, and/or
restrictions on movement are common forms of collective punishment used
by Israel against Palestinians for the purpose of retaliation. Recent political
developments show that punishing the collective might become even more
widespread, which was confirmed in mid-August 2016, when the Israeli
Minister of Defense announced a new policy that would include color-coding
Palestinian communities into ‘good’ and ‘bad’.132 Those communities that
Israel considers bad – either because of confrontations or because a member
of the community carries out an attack against Israel – will be punished,
whereas those considered good will receive economic and other benefits.133
Whether this policy becomes official or not, the will of an Israeli Minister to
implement such a policy clearly reflects the normality and wide acceptance
of collective punishments against Palestinians. Another Israeli politician who
recently supported the use of collective punishment against Palestinians
is Nir Barkat, the mayor of Jerusalem. Barkat justified the punishment of
relatives of those suspected of ‘terror attacks’, riots, or even the punishment
of all residents of East Jerusalem, as well as justifying the use of concrete
barriers around Palestinian neighborhoods or villages to restrict the freedom
of movement.134 Regarding the latter he stated that these restrictions would
“pressure the residents to act against terror.”135 These statements show the
official support for the use of collective punishment, further proving the
systematic nature of this policy against Palestinians.
The Case of the Gaza Strip
The main justification used by Israel for the three wars it launched on the
Gaza Strip, in 2008-09, 2012 and 2014 was self-defense. This claim however
has no basis in international law. As the occupying power, Israel cannot
militarily occupy the Gaza Strip and at the same time claim this territory is a
132 Amos Harel, Israeli Collective Punishment, À La Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman, 20 August 2016.
Available at: http://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-1.737665
133 Ibid.
134 Ben White, Jerusalem mayor boasts of collective punishment of city’s Palestinians, 15 September
2016. Available at: https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20160915-jerusalem-mayor-boasts-ofcollective-punishment-of-citys-palestinians/
135 Ibid.
37