Solutions suggested by
KIIs and FGDs
To help increase issuance of civil documentation to Muhamasheen, respondents were asked
what I/NGOs could do. Key asks were (1) increased legal and financial assistance, (2)
awareness raising amongst communities and (3) capacity building of the CRA as well as local
leaders, including sheikhs. It was suggested that this package of services would address the
needs at different levels.
By building the capacity of the CRA and local leaders, barriers and obstacles for the
Muhamasheen could be identified and addressed. Further, if the Muhamasheen were able
to see legal identity documents being issued to other community members, confidence in the
process would increase leading to higher demand.
Solutions suggested
by KIIs and FGDs
In turn, those Muhamasheen in receipt of legal identity and civil documents would benefit from
an increase in access to public services and civil rights, reducing the impact of discrimination
and fostering a greater sense of equality and inclusion in Yemeni society.
5
At the Civil Registration Authority (Photo: Martin Clutterbuck/NRC)
6
Conclusion and
Recommendations
By helping the Muhamasheen through the process and covering the associated costs, civil
registration would become much more accessible and affordable.
Civil Registration Authority (Photo: Martin Clutterbuck/NRC)
Conclusion and
Recommendations
6.1
Conclusion
As the Yemeni legal framework recognizes the right to legal identity and civil
documentation for all Yemenis, including the Muhamasheen, the key challenge is
realization of that right in practice. According to NRC surveys, the rate of possession of
national ID documentation by the Muhamasheen could be as low as 22 per cent (22%).
Forty-two per cent (42%) of Muhamasheen children are estimated to lack birth
certificates, depriving them of access to school and health services and resulting
in protection risks such as increased child labour and child marriage. Without such
documents, life for the Muhamasheen in Yemen is much harder than necessary. Their
ability to access humanitarian assistance, register businesses and even rent property is
limited, affecting their life opportunities.
The barriers identified by the Muhamasheen include the cost and complexity of the
process and a strong sense of discriminatory treatment, both within the community
and by authorities, leading to a reluctance to apply for documents. A further evidentiary
barrier is the fact that parents of the Muhamasheen also lack national ID documents.
Such documents, or alternative proof of Yemeni origin, are necessary for authorities to
confirm legal identity.
Yemeni authorities are aware of the challenges but lack resources and capacity to address
these issues. Historically entrenched discriminatory attitudes within the community must
also be overcome.