28
A. Brun
if, as a Dane, I reside in France, I have to have the same rights as French
nationals and this from the first day of my stay. Even outside the EU, any
member state has to give me consular protection, under the same conditions
as those applied to its nationals. And, if I receive the rights to vote in municipal and European elections, it is always under the same conditions as the
nationals of the state where I reside.
Being considered as if I were a national in my country of residence,
where is the need for asking for the nationality of that country, as long as the
EU respects diversity? One of my obligations as an EU citizen is to respect
my host country and to participate fairly in its social and political life. But
why should I ask for its nationality, if I still feel French, German or Polish?
Of course, there is a well-known limited number of exceptions to this
national treatment and some discriminations remain.
The purpose of the ‘Let me vote’ initiative is to abolish one of them.
It is ambitious in its scope, by covering all ‘political’ elections, regional,
legislative, referenda, presidential, etc. Due to the diversity of elections in
member states, it would of course not be possible to enter into a precise
enumeration. I understand also that the initiative suggests giving the rights
to all EU residents, not only to long-term or permanent ones. This is in line
with existing rights to vote in municipal and European elections.
Nevertheless, it can be useful to recall that the number of citizens concerned is rather limited. In official documents from the European
Commission, the figure of 12 million people is frequently quoted to measure
the total number of EU citizens residing in a member state other than their
own.
Granting the right to vote to EU citizens will therefore hardly modify the
political landscape in any member state, while it will contribute to the
respect of EU citizens’ fundamental rights, in particular the right to participate in regular elections in the country where they reside as laid down in
Article 3 of the First Protocol to the European Convention on Human Rights.
It will also contribute to reducing the so-called ‘democratic deficit’ by fully
guaranteeing their representation in EU legislation through the vote of their
host country government in the Council and the position taken by national
parliaments in EU procedures according to the rules laid down by the Treaty.
Obviously, this representation is not guaranteed in the situation mentioned by Rainer Bauböck where EU citizens lose their voting rights in
national elections in their countries of origin.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents