2.2 B: Statelessness in the news
Duration: 45-60 minutes
Instructions:
Level of complexity: 3
1. Assign the participants (either in small groups or
individually) one of the articles below to examine. Feel
free to also add / use local articles about statelessness or
others that might be particularly relevant for the group.
You can find the articles in Appendix X. Here are the
links to the originals:
Knowledge/Subjects:
Civics, Media Studies, Social Studies, Politics
Article A. Living in a sea of trash: Sabah’s stateless
children face bleak future:
https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/asia/
sabah-stateless-children-sea-gypsies-bajau-laut-11561194
Article B. Stateless kids causing a headache for Sabah
authorities:
https://reliefweb.int/report/bangladesh/hundreds-thousands-rohingya-people-are-trapped-stateless-limbo
Article C. Thousands find themselves stateless in the
Dominican Republic:
https://cronkite.asu.edu/buffett/dr/the_stateless.html
Article D. Hundreds of thousands of Rohingya people
trapped in stateless limbo:
https://www.thestar.com.my/
news/nation/2020/02/09/
stateless-pelahu-kids-causing-a-headache-for-sabah-authorities
Article E. I found a country, but lost my brother - Stateless activist:
http://news.trust.org/item/20191006223443-qazhk/
Skills:
Comparative Analysis, Critical thinking,
Deductive reasoning, Empathy, Reading
Comprehension, Research
Values/Attitudes:
Sense of identity, Value diversity
Objectives:
• For participants to critically reflect on how
media portrays stateless people, the subconscious effects of media representation and the
multifaceted ways of presenting information.
Materials:
Copies of the news articles
(one for each group of 3-4)
2. Give the participants 15-20 minutes to go through their articles and to examine how statelessness, citizenship
and rights are discussed in the article. Have the participants think about and write down answers to the following
questions (if applicable to their article):
a. What is the article about? Is statelessness the main topic? What other topics are being discussed?
b. Who is talking about statelessness? (Is it the author, an expert quoted, stateless people etc.)
c. What tone is the author/speaker using to talk about statelessness/citizenship/rights? Why do you
think this is?
d. Are stateless people portrayed as outsiders, victims or a problem group?
e. Is there a message that is trying to be conveyed about statelessness? If so, what do you think that
message is?
f. Do you think this is an accurate representation of statelessness? If not, what do you think is
misrepresented or not represented completely?
g. How are newspaper articles different from photographs when telling a story? Were you able to form
your own conclusions based on facts or did you feel the story was leading you to particular
conclusions?
Further the Activity:
Statelessness can be portrayed through several media. A great way to discuss about the issue is through comics!
Shapeless Shapes is a beautifully designed graphic novel about identity, belonging, history, freedom, discrimination, injustice, activism and statelessness. You can order a copy of the physical book through online book sellers
or read it as an ebook here: https://files.institutesi.org/Shapeless_shapes.pdf
39
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents