474
Melbourne University Law Review
[Vol 40:456
Section 40(1) of the Citizenship Act prescribes that the Minister (or an
authorised delegate) may request that the applicant, ‘[f]or the purposes of the
Minister being satisfied of the identity of [the applicant] … provide one or
more specified personal identifiers’. Personal identifiers include: ‘fingerprints
or handprints of a person … a measurement of a person’s height and weight; a
photograph or other image of a person’s face and shoulders; an iris scan; [and]
a person’s signature’.98
However, there are no guidelines available as to what information the
Minister (or an authorised delegate) will take into account when making an
initial assessment as to an applicant’s identity with respect to an assessment
under s 21(8) of the Citizenship Act. Similarly, there are no guidelines as to
what standard of proof is required, and on whom the burden falls, with
respect to a conferral of citizenship under that provision.99 Additionally, the
term ‘identity’ is not defined in the Citizenship Act or any other relevant
legislation or regulations. There is no information on the Department’s
website (or otherwise publicly available) about the application process for
conferral of citizenship under s 21(8), and the conferral of citizenship form
does not include the option of conferral pursuant to that section.100
At the time of writing, there were only two published tribunal decisions
about the application of s 21(8) (conferral). In the first decision, the applicant
(AP) was born in Australia in 2010 to a Nepalese mother and an unidentified
98
Citizenship Act ss 10(1)(a)--(e).
99
The extent of the guidance provided to decision-makers is as follows: ‘Applications which are
considered to meet the requirements of this section must be referred to [the] Citizenship
Policy Section through the Citizenship Helpdesk’: Department of Immigration and Border
Protection (Cth), Australian Citizenship Instructions (2015) 62 [5.14.2]. The Instructions
further state, at 1, that:
The instructions provide guidance on policy in relation to the interpretation of, and the
exercise of powers under, the Act and the Regulations. Decision-makers should be mindful that policy must not be applied inflexibly. Policy cannot constrain the exercise of delegated powers under the Act.
Similarly, the instructions on s 24(3) identity requirements state, at 85 [5.27.2], that:
Section 24(3) requires that the Minister must not approve the person becoming an Australian citizen unless the Minister is satisfied of the identity of the person. In addition to
being a legislative requirement under the Act, the Australian community expects that decision-makers will not approve a person for citizenship if they are not satisfied of the person’s identity.
100
Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Cth), Form 1290: Application for
Australian Citizenship ---- Other Situations (2016). The first few pages of the form, which
discuss ‘eligibility’ to apply for citizenship via this form, do not specify the statelessness
safeguard provided for by 21(8) of the Citizenship Act.