The Role of Colonialism in Creating and Perpetuating Statelessness in Southern Africa
for how they contribute to ongoing inequalities and discrimination.29 Far more work
is required to sensitise societies that many people are perpetuating the very tactics
previously used against themselves or their own ancestors and family members.
Unfortunately, because statelessness is a forgotten issue and stateless people are
invisible, they lack advocates to raise awareness of the costs.
VI. COSTS TO SOCIETY
Nationalism does not resolve social issues. It has proven successful in rallying political
support, but increases long-term risks and problems.30 Creating and perpetuating
statelessness does not resolve any root issues of social discontent; it worsens them.
Some of the costs include development, health, and security.
Statelessness deepens inequality and creates challenges to achieving
development goals. Nationality is a key element to achieve all development goals,
including economic growth, peaceful and inclusive societies, equality, and access
to education.31 Statelessness further threatens the ability to measure progress.
Low-income countries are under pressure to demonstrate results and promote
accountability against development goals.32 It is impossible to assess how well a
country or community is achieving development goals locally or regionally without
accurate statistics that preclude large numbers of undocumented and unaccountedfor people. Adequately informed statistics and measurements are crucial to
development.
No country or population within the region can develop independently. A
country is most stable and prosperous if its surrounding countries are stable and
prosperous. Regional cooperation is required. Subjugating and exposing fellow
Africans to statelessness and preventing them from reaching their full potential
hamper national and regional development.
Poor living conditions, displacement, and lack of access to services make
stateless populations particularly vulnerable to health issues, including communicable
diseases. The COVID-19 pandemic provided a stark reminder that public health
affects all of society. COVID-19 disproportionately impacted the most economically
disadvantaged communities and stateless people were excluded from or struggled
to access vaccines.33 People living outside the scope of state-sponsored health
services and in subpar conditions have low immunisation rates and are vulnerable
to infectious diseases.
It is in the collective interest to ensure everyone has access to healthcare,
United Nations Human Rights Council (HRC) ‘Acting High Commissioner for Human Rights Nada Al-Nashif – Address
to UN Human Rights Council Interactive Dialogue on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples’ (28 September 2022), available at
www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2022/09/acting-high-commissioner-addressing-legacies-colonialism-can-contribute
30
Ottilia Maunganidze ‘The “illegal migrant” red herring’ ISS Today (24 October 2018), available at https://issafrica.org/
iss-today/the-illegal-migrant-red-herring
31
Tendayi Bloom Bronwen Manby & Khadija Badri ‘Why citizenship is relevant to sustainable development: Considerations
for the 2019 High Level Political Forum’ European Network on Statelessness (May 2019).
32
The Hague & WISER op cit note 21.
33
Mkhululi Chimoio ‘COVID-19: Vaccinating stateless people in South Africa’ Africa Renewal (21 January 2022),
available at www.un.org/africarenewal/magazine/february-2022/covid-19-vaccinating-stateless-people-south-africa
29
91
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents