AHMR African Human Mobilty Review - Volume 8 No 3, SEP-DEC 2022
of colonised countries around the world, as occurred in many countries throughout
Africa.26 Consequently, this discriminatory approach was prevalent in nationality
laws around the world until recent decades, although it is less common now.
There are two main legal consequences arising from the dependent nationality
approach that result in gender discrimination. First, women can be required to
automatically give up their own nationality upon marriage to a foreign national and
acquire their husband’s.27 Conversely, some laws also restrict women from passing
their nationality to their foreign husbands upon marriage on an equal basis with men’s
right to pass nationality to their wives. This restriction is a concern where the male
spouse is stateless or at risk of statelessness. As recognised by the UN Human Rights
Committee (HRC) in a case concerning Mauritius in 1981, this restriction impedes
the right to family and is discriminatory on the basis of sex.28 Secondly, due to the
preference for following the male lineage, nationality of children passes through the
man, barring women from passing their nationality to their children.29 As such, many
countries enacted laws that require women to lose their nationality upon marriage
and restrict women from passing nationality to their children. No such restrictions
apply to men who married foreign nationals or became a parent. The consequences
can be severe. For example, children who cannot acquire nationality from their father
can become stateless if their father dies, abandons the family, becomes stateless, or
cannot prove his nationality.30 Women married to foreign nationals risk losing their
acquired nationality and becoming stateless if their status changes, such as through
divorce or death or abandonment by the husband.31
As of 2022, more than 50 countries worldwide have laws restricting women’s
equal rights to acquire, retain, or change their own nationality.32 A total of 25
countries still have laws that restrict women from passing their nationality to their
children.33 For example, in Eswatini, the Constitution states that children can only
acquire nationality from their fathers.34 There is an exception if the child is born
out of wedlock and not legally or customarily recognised by the father, which is the
only circumstance where a Swazi mother can pass her nationality to her child. There
are still many countries worldwide, including Malawi and Lesotho, that restrict a
woman from passing her nationality to her non-citizen spouse, although no such
restriction applies to men.35 Overall, there has been significant progress in the
Southern African region to reform gender discriminatory nationality laws. As one
of the last remaining countries in the region to include gender discrimination in
Ibid.
Ibid at 16.
Aumeeruddy-Cziffra v Mauritius (35/1978), Views, CCPR/C/12/D/35/1978.
29
International Law Association op cit note 25 at 18.
30
CEDAW GR 32 op cit note 6 para 61.
31
Ibid para 60.
32
UNHCR ‘Background Note’ op cit note 11 at 2.
33
Ibid at 2.
34
Constitution of the Kingdom of Eswatini, 2005, Article 43. This provision applies to children born after 2005. According to the 1992 Citizenship Act the same provisions apply to children born after 1992.
35
Bronwen Manby ‘Statelessness in Southern Africa’ (2012) Briefing paper for the UNHCR at 9.
26
27
28
22