World Report
Statelessness in the COVID-19 pandemic
Millions of people have no nationality and are being overlooked in the response to COVID-19.
Talha Burki reports.
There are several ways that you can
become stateless. You could have your
nationality revoked. Perhaps your
father has disappeared, and you live in
a place which does not permit mothers
to pass on their nationality. Perhaps
your country of origin has broken
up or been otherwise transformed.
Thousands of residents of Kuwait
were not granted citizenship after the
Gulf state gained independence from
the UK in 1961. After the dissolution
of the Soviet Union, Estonia and
Latvia demanded that ethnic Russians
living within their borders pass a
language test to become citizens. The
two Baltic republics are now home
to roughly half of Europe’s estimated
528 000 stateless people. But for the
most part, statelessness is inherited. If
your parents have no nationality, it is
extremely hard for you to acquire one.
According to the UN High
Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR),
4·2 million people across 76 countries
are known to be stateless. However,
this figure is likely to represent no more
than a third of the overall stateless
population. Three-quarters of people
without a nationality are from minority
groups. The Rohingya were stripped
of Burmese citizenship in 1982. The
500 000–600 000 who remain in
Myanmar’s Rakhine State are subject
to discriminatory laws and sporadic
pogroms. 2017 saw a brutal crackdown
by the Burmese army. Reports emerged
of murder, arson, mass rape, and
torture. The violence prompted several
hundred thousand Rohingya to flee to
Bangladesh. The country now hosts
almost 1 million Rohingya, 600 000 of
whom live in the 23 settlements that
make up the Kutupalong-Balukhali
Expansion Site.
Whether settled or part of refugee or
migrant communities, to be stateless
is to be vulnerable. Rohingya who
www.thelancet.com Vol 397 April 24, 2021
attempt to leave Myanmar face an
astonishing array of risks from people
traffickers, ranging from debt bondage
and extortion to slavery. Roma
communities in Europe are subjected
to xenophobia and hate speech. The
invisibility of stateless populations can
result in children being excluded from
“‘There is a very real risk that a
lot of stateless people will not
get the vaccine’...”
immunisation campaigns, and the lack
of documentation makes it difficult to
find jobs. If stateless populations have
any access to health care, it is usually
limited to emergency care. If their
residency status is unsettled they risk
lengthy periods of detention, and in
times of crisis, their vulnerability only
increases.
A new report from the European
Network on Statelessness (ENS)
has outlined how Europe’s stateless
populations have fared during the
COVID-19 pandemic. The authors heard
from stakeholders in 20 countries.
Respondents described the difficulties
inherent in maintaining physical dis
tancing in overcrowded settlements
and in apartments accommodating
several families. An interviewee in
Bulgaria noted that the pandemic has
been expensive. “You pay to visit the
doctor, you pay for the PCR test, you pay
for medicine. We have to pay for masks,
gloves”, they said.
The social security schemes and aid
packages that European governments
rolled out in the wake of the pandemic
have usually been restricted to citizens.
“Stateless populations are deprived
of a lot of welfare support that others
are entitled to”, explains Nina Murray,
head of policy and research at the ENS
and coauthor of the new report. “They
have struggled to mitigate the spread
of the virus with non-pharmaceutical
interventions and they have to keep
working, if they can, which makes
it even more difficult to keep their
community safe from infection.”
Stateless people tend to be in the
informal economy, in sectors where pay
is contingent on work. For example,
they could work as day labourers or
sell scrap metal. “A lot of people have
suddenly lost their sources of work.
They have been pushed into extreme
poverty”, Murray told The Lancet.
An interviewee for the ENS report
recounted the story of a man who had
been refused cancer surgery by the
UK National Health Service before the
pandemic. He was instructed to return
to his country of origin for treatment,
although the country in question had
twice refused to accept him. The report
added that there have been instances
in which people with severe COVID-19
have died after being unwilling or
unable to obtain medical care in the
UK. “The British Government has
guaranteed that no-one will be charged
for COVID-19 care, but there is still a
great deal of concern among people
with insecure immigration status that
they will be billed if they access health
care”, said Murray.
A survey by R2P, a Ukrainian nongovernmental organisation, found
that 46% of stateless respondents had
been refused access to a community
doctor over the course of the pandemic
because they lacked identification. Noncitizens often worry that if they make
themselves visible to health services,
they will be reported to immigration
services. The Irish Government has
taken steps to ensure that information
on patients does not leave the health
department, but such measures are
rare.
Amal de Chickera is co-director of the
Institute on Statelessness and Inclusion.
For more on statelessness in
a global pandemic see
https://www.refworld.org/
docid/5f50a81e4.html
Talha Burki was on the expert
advisory group for the European
Network for Statelessness report
but was not involved in
researching or writing it.
1529