nationality at birth because their parents did not have a domicile. If they had a domicile
at the birth, the children would automatically have acquired nationality. Therefore, the
children whose parents did not have a domicile at the birth will also be automatically
excluded from the acquisition of nationality through declaration.
Children born to parents who are unable to pass on their nationality to their children
19.
Another gap in Hungarian law which can result in the failure to prevent statelessness at
birth arises from the fact that the law does not envisage situations in which parents who
have a nationality may not be able to pass it on to their children, particularly when born
abroad. This may happen for various reasons including gender discrimination in
nationality laws in some countries, which do not allow mothers to pass on their
nationality to their child under the same conditions as fathers.24 In this case, if a child is
born to a mother with nationality of one of those countries and if the father is stateless,
unknown or unwilling to cooperate, the child will be born stateless in Hungary and no
safeguard will apply to her/him.
20.
Obtaining nationality through the process of declaration can, in some cases, provide a
solution. However, the restrictive application of the concept of domicile is likely to
exclude a significant portion of those most in need of the safeguard. As already stated
above, parents will only be able to establish a domicile in Hungary if they have already
obtained a permanent resident status, subject to strict material conditions, or if they are
refugees or beneficiaries of subsidiary protection.
Children born to beneficiaries of international protection who are unable to pass on their nationality
to their children due to impossibility or prohibition to contact the authorities of the country of origin
24
21.
In addition to the situation where the country of origin has legal provisions that do not
allow nationals to pass on their nationality to their children under certain circumstances,
children born to beneficiaries of international protection in Hungary also face the
challenge of being stateless at birth. This is because their parents may have a wellfounded reason for not contacting the authorities of their country of origin to establish
and register the nationality of their children after birth. For example, such contact may
expose them to a risk of persecution or serious harm and even lead to the cancellation
of their protection status. Hungary has not taken sufficient consideration of this
situation when designing laws to prevent statelessness at birth.
22.
This impossibility or prohibition of contact applies to cases in which the transmission of
nationality to children born abroad is not automatic; but it can also apply to cases in
which it is automatic. In the former scenario, the children will not be able to acquire
their parents’ nationality, as transmission is subject to conditions that require contact
with the authorities of the country of origin. In the latter scenario, while the children
will, as a matter of legal principle, acquire their parents’ nationality at birth, this would
not translate to actual documentation of nationality. Furthermore, it is possible that the
competent authorities in the country would question or not recognise the nationality of
children born abroad to refugees. This places the child at significant risk of statelessness.
23.
Again, declaration is not always a viable solution for this group of children to obtain
Hungarian nationality. First, if the parents only have a tolerated status or are still in an
For the list of countries, see UNHCR, Revised Background Note on Gender Equality, Nationality Laws and
Statelessness, 8 March 2013, available at http://www.refworld.org/docid/4f59bdd92.html.