Statelessness & Citizenship Review
2019
1(1)
so. 102 However, the lack of reported improvement is marginally more
commonplace in rural areas. 103
When asked whether access to government healthcare services beyond the
estate has improved since the 2003 grant of citizenship, the majority of
interviewees (27/30) indicated that access has improved, with a near equal
representation of women and men (14 women and 13 men) reporting this so as to
suggest that there was no gendered division in terms of physical access. 104 Three
interviewees were unable to comment due to a lack of experience using these
services. However, two of the three who were unable to comment due to a lack of
experience responded from a place of resignation when discussing personal access
to healthcare services, one of whom was Kumuthuvalli, a 28-year-old female from
Passara: ‘Those who are poor, still they live like that — either before or after
citizenship. Those who have the money, they can improve their health, but for the
poor, nothing changes’. 105 The other was her neighbour, Anandan, a 53 year-old
male from Passara, who remarked: ‘We are living in isolation. For this reason we
don’t know how to go to town and buy medicines or other things. We stay in this
place only, because we don’t know of any changes’. 106 Though the words of two
individuals do not indicate a trend, their lack of experience using healthcare
services beyond the estate indicate a self-perceived sense of non-entitlement to a
world outside the estate, and hence should not be overlooked.
2
Education
The majority of questionnaire survey respondents indicated that access to schools
outside one’s respective estate had improved since the 2003 grant of citizenship,
with women predominating in this response. 107 However, more than three-quarters
of those who responded ‘no’ when asked whether access to schools outside the
estate had improved since 2003 are from Dickoya, indicating a serious lack of
access to public education in this community despite their recently acquired
citizenship. 108
102 It should be noted that 77 of 100 respondents (37 women and 40 men) indicated that they did
have access to government healthcare services beyond the estate prior to 2003. See Figure 1.
103 See Figure 2.
104 Similarly, the majority of interviewees (13 female and 15 male) indicated that they did have
105
106
107
108
access to government healthcare services beyond the estate prior to the 2003 grant of
citizenship.
Interview with Anonymous (Patrick Balazo, 10 August 2016).
Interview with Anonymous (Patrick Balazo, 10 August 2016).
Figure 3.
Figure 4.
20
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents