introduction21
nomenclature,there is no possibility in a Jewish state for an Israeli nationality. Israel is a Jewish state, and the Jewish state becomes a state of the
Jewish people. Citizenship in a Jewish state becomes Jewish citizenship.
And nationalism in a Jewish state becomes Jewish nationalism. Taken
together, this dynamic is shown to have three profound effects on Arab
development, inclusion and identity. First, the development of a contradictory and deficient Palestinian social and political identity in Israel
results in a situation where both Arabs and Jews have an incomplete and
deficient Israeli collective identity, albeit in different ways. Second, contradictions in the Israeli incorporation regime make it conceptually,
politically, and legally impossible to define the Israeli nation, or Israeli
nationality. This prevents Arab citizens from developing any genuine
identification with Israeli society. Here I outline several legal petitions,
repeatedly rejected by the Israeli Supreme Court, which requested the
legal and political definition and formation of an ‘Israeli’ nation separate
from a ‘Jewish’ nation. As I explain, the Court’s consistent refusal to legally
define an ‘Israeli’ nation is fuelled by the understanding that any conceptual separation between ‘Israeli’ and ‘Jewish’ would have juridico-political
repercussions for the entrenchment of Jewish control within the state.
And third, contradictions in the country’s incorporation regime make it
impossible for Arabs in Israel to have and practice citizenship in any
meaningful way. The chapter outlines a sample of the notable social science research conducted on Arabs in Israel, and compares their respective
and various formulations of Arab citizenship and its dynamics and relations of exception. This body of critical scholarship is shown to deconstruct the internal contradictions and paradoxes that emerge, both
conceptually and in practice, with the state’s provision of Israeli citizenship to Palestinians on the one hand, and with its unabridged fusing of
‘Israeli’ and ‘Jewish’ identity and nationhood on the other. The chapter
ends by pointing out that the above academic literature has largely focused
on the question of what Palestinian citizenship entails or lacks, rather
than asking how the space for Palestinian citizenship has been (re)shaped.
The concept of stateless citizenship is therefore introduced as part of an
answer to the question of how Palestinian citizenship came to embody its
existing exclusionary dynamics.
Together, the first five chapters of the book show that the mechanisms
of control and exclusion developing out of the Zionist incorporation
regime shape both the changing settler-colonial boundaries of the Israeli
polity and, by extension, its hierarchical citizenship framework. At a fundamental level, and despite their citizenship status, the Palestinian
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents