July-December 2020
Volume: 10, No: 2, pp. 227 – 243
ISSN: 2046-4436
e-ISSN: 2046-4444
https://journals.tplondon.com/bc
Received: 10 June 2020 Accepted: 17 July 2020
DOI: https://doi.org/10.33182/bc.v10i2.1046
Book Review
Introduction
A suicide attempt by Muhammad Bouazizi in Tunisia in 2010 was the beginning of important social
and political developments in the Middle East. The events in the Arab geography aiming at the
change of governance and affecting the fundamental dynamics, especially in Egypt, Libya, and
Syria, have led to the massive migrations that have impacted almost all countries of the World by
going beyond the borders of the countries. This situation has set the groundwork for social and
political debates regarding the residence or return of Syrians in Turkey and Lebanon, where they
are allowed to passage through the border. However, it is also possible to express that Syrians have
built the backdrop of new problems due to their citizenship being idle. The “old1” phrase used by
Syrians who remained away from their own country indicates the ambiguous situation of Syria and
their old lives. Syrians, who cannot reach the documents they left behind because of the war and
now cannot prove that they are Syrian, can face various difficulties in the countries they have
migrated. The obligation to renew the passports and identity cards that they have brought along with
them and have been deformed over time is a reality that most of the Syrians cannot afford because
of cost and security reasons. As a result of these components and loaded negative arguments, the
definition of Syrian used for Syrians staying in foreign states today does not go beyond
responsibilities and sanctions for certain individuals. With a reverse reading, citizenship emerges
as the starting point of the bond and mutual responsibility established between individuals and the
State. In a study conducted by UNHCR (2015, p. 15), stateless children were asked to identify
themselves, then they often identified themselves with an adjective that contains negativity such as
‘invisible’, ‘strangers’, ‘keeping a low profile’, ‘worthless’ and ’a stray dog’, reflecting their point
of view towards themselves.
Because individuals who have settled in the territory of other countries by migrating from Syria
and citizenship is reserved via the father as required by Syria’s own constitution, the emergence of
sociological problems as well as various legal problems are seen today. The UN (1954, p. 6), defines
a stateless person as one “who is not considered as a national by any State under the operation of
its law”. This definition deprives the individual of fundamental rights and prevents the individual
from imposing the responsibility of any State. In this respect, “Statelessness is not merely a legal
problem, but it is a human problem” (Batchelor, 1998, p. 159). That is why statelessness becomes
the source of the problems that individuals will experience in the future. The absence of an
individual’s commitment to a State or not being registered to a State means that he/she is deprived
of important fundamental rights such as education, health, and travel. This situation, which
resembles a flag-free ship in the middle of the sea (Altuğ, 1963, p. 202), always carries individuals
1
https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2014/10/23/the-loss-of-a-nation
Border Crossing
Transnational Press London