TILBURG LAW REVIEW
Journal of International and European Law
Maria Jose Recalde-Vela, Sangita Jaghai-Bajulaiye and Caia
Vlieks, ‘The State of Statelessness Research: 5 Years Later’
(2019) 24(2) Tilburg Law Review pp. 139–141. DOI: https://
doi.org/10.5334/tilr.148
EDITORIAL
The State of Statelessness Research: 5 Years Later
Maria Jose Recalde-Vela*, Sangita Jaghai-Bajulaiye† and Caia Vlieks‡
The idea for this special TLR issue on citizenship and statelessness was initiated at the first PhD Workshop
on Citizenship and Statelessness hosted at Tilburg University and funded by the Tilburg University Alumni
Fund in September 2018. This special is a result of rapidly growing interest in citizenship and statelessness among early career researchers worldwide and reflects innovative research and new developments in
researching citizenship and statelessness issues, particularly focusing on interdisciplinary research.
Statelessness has been traditionally understood as a legal issue: it denotes the lack of legal membership
of an individual in a state. Efforts to reduce statelessness have traditionally been of a legal nature, through
conventions and efforts to change laws that cause statelessness. Therefore, work related to statelessness—
both academic and in practice—has primarily had a legal focus. Over the last ten years, however, major
developments have taken place, which have resulted in the issue of statelessness gaining prominence and
being acknowledged as an important issue on its own, and in the academic domain, as a fascinating field of
academic inquiry. Economists, anthropologists, social scientists, human geographers, historians, and people
from other backgrounds have become interested in conducting academic research on this issue.
This became visible in, among others, the first special issue on statelessness published by Tilburg Law
Review in 2014, which compiled the work of over 30 scholars and practitioners working on statelessness
and spanned two volumes, across various disciplines. Due to the relatively small size of academics working
in the field of statelessness, it has become like a small family where faces are familiar, and newcomers are
welcome. This has allowed for people from different backgrounds to come together in events and become
interested in the works of others who might work outside of their own discipline, but still related to statelessness. Two recent events come to mind that showcase this. The first is was an academic meeting organized
by the Institute on Statelessness and Inclusion, the NYU Centre for Global Affairs, and Open Society Justice
Initiative, which took place in New York in mid-2017. In this academic meeting, senior and junior academics
doing research on statelessness or closely related fields came together and discussed some of the most pressing issues they encountered in their own work.
The second event, the PhD Workshop on Citizenship and Statelessness was a follow-up from the 2017
academic meeting in NYC. This PhD workshop brought together 15 PhD students from around the world
and from very different academic disciplines for four days to discuss not only their own research but also to
attend masterclasses by various experts from different fields whose research is interesting for statelessness
research. They learned about statelessness and digital data from Dr. Linnet Taylor (TLS & TILT), about
citizenship and statelessness from literary and philosophical perspectives from Dr. Michiel Bot (TLS) and
Mr. Isshaq Al-Barbary (Palestinian researcher), about innovative manners to conduct field research from
Professor Morgan Goodwin (TLS) and all about researching statelessness by Dr. Laura van Waas (TLS and
co-director of the Institute on Statelessness and Inclusion). Keynote speeches were given by Emeritus
Professor Gerard-René de Groot (Maastricht University) on citizenship and statelessness, social identity and
‘genuine link’ from a legal perspective, Ms. Zahra Albarazi (Senior Researcher, Institute on Statelessness and
Inclusion; External PhD TLS) on academia and activism through field research on statelessness in the Middle
East and North Africa, and Mr. Oluseyi Bajulaiye (retired Senior UN official) gave invaluable insights into his
career journey and spoke about career opportunities in and beyond academia.
The PhD Workshop participants also brainstormed about the future of statelessness academic research.
These discussions yielded two concrete results. The first is a network, the Global PhDs on Statelessness (GPS),
which will launch in a few months, and this Tilburg Law Review special issue on statelessness. This special
issue contains two case notes and five articles. Vlieks’ case note covers Tjebbes and Others v Minister van
* PhD researcher, Tilburg University, Tilburg, The Netherlands, m.j.recalde-vela@tilburguniversity.edu
†
PhD researcher, Tilburg University, Tilburg, The Netherlands, s.jaghai@tilburguniversity.edu
‡
Lecturer/researcher, Tilburg University, Tilburg, The Netherlands, c.vlieks@tilburguniversity.edu