ZIONISM FROM THE STANDPOINT OF ITS VICTIMS
81
O r Stanley C o o k ’s view of the country:
. , . rapid deterioration, which {it would seem) was only
temporarily stopped by the energetic Crusaders. Modern
travellers have often noticed the inherent weakness of the
characters of the inhabitants and, like Robinson, have realized
that, for the return of prosperity, "nothing is wanted but the
hand of the man to till the ground.”
O r, finally, R. A . S. Macalister:
It is no exaggeration to say that throughout these long
centuries the native inhabitants of Palestine do not appear to
have made a single contribution of any kind whatsoever to
material civilization. It was perhaps the most unprogressive
country on the face of the earth. Its entire culture was
derivative . . . 10
These, then, are some of the main points that must be made
about the background of Zionism in European imperialist or
colonialist attitudes. For whatever it may have done for Jews,
Zionism essentially saw Palestine as the European imperialist
did, as an empty territory paradoxically “ filled” with ignoble or
perhaps even dispensable natives; it allied itself, as Chaim
Weizmann quite clearly said after W orld War I, with the
imperial powers in carrying out its plans for establishing a new
Jewish state in Palestine, and it did not think except in negative
terms o f “ the natives,” who were passively supposed to accept
the plans made for their land; as even Zionist historians like
Yehoshua Porath and Neville Mandel have em pirically shown,
the ideas o f Jewish colonizers in Palestine (well before World
War I) always met with unmistakable native resistance, not
because the natives thought that Jews were evil, but because
most natives do not take kindly to having their territory settled
by foreigners;11 m oreover, in form ulating the concept o f a
Jewish nation “ reclaiming” its own territory, Zionism not only
accepted the generic racial concepts o f European culture, it
also banked on the fact that Palestine was actually pcopied not
by an advanced but by a backward people, over which it ought
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents