18 | PROTECTING STATELESS PERSONS FROM ARBITRARY DETENTION IN BULGARIA
3. KEY ISSUES OF CONCERN
This section sets out and analyses the situation in
Bulgaria in relation to the key issues of concern regarding
prevention of arbitrary detention of stateless persons.
3.1 IDENTIFICATION & DETERMINATION
PROCEDURES
States have a human rights obligation to identify
statelessness before subjecting people to immigration
detention.69 Bulgaria does not yet apply this obligation. As
mentioned in Section 2.2. of the report, Bulgaria does not
yet have a dedicated statelessness determination
procedure, but there is a draft law adopted at first
reading in Parliament on 15 June 2016 that introduces
such a procedure. However, as drafted currently, the
status of a stateless person would be accessible only to
persons who were born in or entered legally into the
territory of Bulgaria and who at the same time hold a
permanent or long-term residence permit. As such, the
scope of the draft law would exclude the vast majority of
stateless persons in the country, and would be contrary to
Bulgaria’s obligations under the 1954 Statelessness
Convention and under international human rights law.
The draft, submitted before the Bulgarian Parliament on
28 April 2016 by the Bulgarian Government (‘Council of
Ministers’) introduces in §22 a new Chapter Two "a",
Articles 21b-21g, with the title: “Granting the status of
stateless person in Bulgaria under the Law on Ratification of
the Convention on the Status of Stateless Persons, adopted by
the United Nations Organization in New York on September
28, 1954”.70 Currently, as of September 2016, the draft
law is pending adoption at a final second reading.71
According to the Bulgarian law-making procedure,
between the first and the second readings it is possible to
make amendments to the concrete provisions of the law.
In relation to the definition of stateless person, Article
21b(1) of the draft law provides:
The status of stateless persons may be granted to a
foreigner who was born or has entered legally on
the territory of Bulgaria, has been granted long-term or
permanent residence and who is not a citizen of any
country in accordance with its legislation.”
The proposed provision only includes foreigners who
cumulatively meet the three conditions stated therein,
excluding foreigners who did not enter Bulgaria legally
and those lawfully residing foreigners who do not hold
permanent or long-term residence permit. In comparison,
the UNHCR Handbook and the UNHCR Guidelines on
Statelessness NO.2 (HCR/GS/12/02), paragraph 17,
state that “everyone in a State’s territory must have
access to statelessness determination procedures” and
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents