On September 30, 2007, Natalia married Grzegorz S. Kowal, a U.S. citizen. R. at 85. Natalia and Grzegorz have one U.S. citizen child, Sophie Kowal. Natalia’s husband filed a Form I-130 Application for Alien Relative on her behalf on November 6, 2009. R. at 83. This application has not been adjudicated despite various inquiries from Natalia and her counsel. On October 23, 2009, ICE arrested all four of the Jourbinas at their homes in the early morning. Natalia, Polina, and Tatiana were released the same day. Boris was released on January 15, 2010. All four Jourbinas Intensive and were Supervision later downgraded Supervision due to initially placed on Appearance Program (ISAP), to their an ordinary compliance the Order with of the program’s requirements. Then, on December 22, 2009, pursuant to a national policy to create a native, ethnically pure majority and exclude persons it deemed non-Kazakh, 15