I. STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION Petitioners, Boris, Tatiana, Natalia, and Polina Jourbina, seek review of an order of the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) dated March 22, 2011 that dismissed the Petitioners’ Motion Reopen Removal Proceedings. Add. at 45-48. action challenges the BIA’s to This arbitrary and capricious dismissal of the motion on the grounds that: the agency failed properly to address—and thus perfunctorily dismissed—the Petitioners’ claim that their recent denationalization because of nonKazak nationality constitutes a change in country conditions in their native Kazakhstan, the central basis for erroneously the Motion reduced nationalization claim to the as one Reopen; the agency Petitioners’ of de- “statelessness” arising from non-discriminatory acts; the agency failed to provide any reasoning or legal analysis when dismissing the Petitioners’ prima facie asylum proffer. 5 arguments and