provide specific examples of violence against nonKazak nationals. Finally, the expert states in her affidavit that “[I]f the Jourbin[as] were returned to Kazakhstan, severe they hardship in would the almost form certainly of denial of face their right to a nationality.” R. at 100. The BIA Petitioners’ failed to arguments Kazakhstan amount nationals and revocation of to that any of the conditions in persecution that their address the for Kazak citizenship non-Kazak government’s now placed them within a group that is routinely persecuted. The failure to consider the central argument in the Petitioners’ motion to reopen constitutes an abuse of discretion and should be reversed. B. The BIA failed to address the Petitioners’ central prima facie asylum claim To refugee, obtain which asylum, an means that 35 applicant he or must she be must a be