Expanding Statelessness Scholarship
new people have been living outside of legal nationality and beyond the reach
of governments since the birth of our state-centric international system but the
meaning and impacts associated with lack of legal nationality are wholly modern.
Legal nationality is used as a prerequisite for enjoying fundamental rights: from
attending school to going to the doctor, from voting in elections to protesting
unfair policies, from working legally to crossing borders. Further, citizenship often
marks friend from enemy, ‘us’ versus ‘them’, in contentious debates about identity
and belonging. It is legal status, but it is also a marker of membership that extends
far beyond ID cards. The power of legal nationality explains why denationalisation
is increasingly used as a weapon against those deemed threats to the state, 18 just
as citizenship is used as a reward for those seen as extraordinary. 19
Therefore, my advice in this discussion is not to necessarily abandon the
concept of ‘statelessness studies’, but rather to undertake this scholarship and
advocacy with full recognition that statelessness is complicated. It cannot be
neatly categorized within any academic discipline or assigned any one-size-fits all
‘solution.’ In order to move this conversation forward, we must resist the urge to
narrow our focus and constrict our scholarly explorations. Indeed, the growing
support and enthusiasm for studying statelessness means that we finally have the
political and academic space to dig deeper and engage with this issue in important,
impactful and diverse ways. This, my friends and colleagues, is where things get
interesting.
18
19
See, eg, Nisha Kapoor, Deport, Deprive, Extradite: 21st Century State Extremism (Verso
2018).
French President Emmanuel Macron promised Malian migrant Mamoudou Gassama
citizenship in 2018, for instance, in recognition of his extraordinary heroics. Nicknamed
‘Spider Man,’ Gassama climbed four stories to save a child dangling from the balcony of a
Paris flat. Kim Willsher, ‘“Spider-Man” of Paris to Get French citizenship after child rescue’
The Guardian (29 May 2018) <https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/may/28/spiderman-of-paris-to-get-french-citizenship-after-rescuing-child>.
169