naturalised citizen must reportedly pay the equivalent of US$3,000 for a passport.125 In 2013,
President Koroma naturalised British journalist Mark Doyle and at least twenty others.126
The requirement for a presidential decree is no great barrier in some countries, such as Senegal, where
presidential approval is a formality after the Ministry of Justice has verified that the conditions for
naturalisation are fulfilled. But in many other countries, the perception is that the naturalisation
procedure is highly politicised and only approved for those who have connections; naturalisation is
therefore effectively available only to elite individuals with the full panoply of documents required,
and the ability to follow their dossier closely through the process. In Côte d’Ivoire, in particular, the
naturalisation process has been much criticised, especially in the case of group naturalisations.127
In Liberia, uniquely in West Africa, the Aliens and Nationality Law gives “exclusive jurisdiction” to
naturalise persons as citizens of Liberia to the circuit courts in each county, which are to hear the
application in open court. The attorney-general may also “designate an immigration officer to conduct
a personal investigation of the person”, on the basis of which the attorney-general may petition the
court in support or opposition to the application.128 The naturalisation process is still not very
accessible, thanks to delays and difficulties with the circuit courts; but Liberia, also unusually, has
committed to naturalise refugees based on long residence in the country, including several thousand
Sierra Leonean former refugees.129
In these circumstances, those who wish to become nationals and show their commitment to a new
country are unable to do so. Instead, they may be forced to obtain documents illicitly. This may be
done in good faith: if the perception is that nationality is generally obtained through a birth certificate,
then seeking a birth certificate in the country even if not born there may be rather an effort to
“naturalise” than an act of fraud. Many “ordinary people” interviewed for this report who were longterm residents in a country where they did not have nationality papers were very hazy on what the
correct procedures should be: they just wanted recognition as nationals in the place where their lives
were centred and they had the strongest ties.
125
Sierra Leone Citizenship (Amendment) Act No. 11 of 2006; Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor,
2010 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices : Sierra Leone, US Department of State, 8 April 2011; “Nasser
Ayoub appeals to President Koroma”, Sierra Express, 15 May 2012
126
“Mark Doyle Subscribes to the oath of allegiance as Sierra Leonean”, Sierra Leone presidency, 5 November
2013; "’We Expect You To Be Good Citizens’ -- President Koroma Admonishes”, Sierra Leone presidency, 11
September 2013, both available at http://www.statehouse.gov.sl/ last accessed 08 July 2014.
127
For example, 8,133 immigrants of Burkinabè origin and their descendants born in Côte d’Ivoire settled in
Bouaflé in central Côte d’Ivoire were naturalised by President Henri Konan Bédié by a collective decree in 1995;
up to 2010, most of the individuals concerned still had no certificates of nationality proving their naturalisation
although this was expressly envisaged by the decree. With the support of UNHCR, the ministry for human rights
undertook awareness raising activities to confirm that these people were Ivorian. This collective naturalisation
is still controversial today : See « Lutte contre l’apatridie : 8.133 postulants a la nationalité ivoirienne obtiennent
leur naturalisation » Government of Cote d’Ivoire 4 March 2013; and « Bradage massif de la nationalité
ivoirienne: Ouattara se sert de Bédié, grosse colère au PDCI », IvoireBusiness.net, 13 Mars 2013 ; additional
information from Paul Koreki, Technical adviser, Ministry of Justice, Human Rights and Civil Liberties, June 2013.
128
Aliens and Nationality Law, 1973, arts 21.1 to 21.5. Among the requirements to naturalise are that a person
must “state that he does not believe in anarchy”.
129
“Liberia grants citizenship to 2,600 Sierra Leone refugees”, AFP, 13 November 2007; Zoom Dosso, “Sierra
Leoneans to Get Liberian Citizenship” New Dawn (Monrovia), 25 August 2010, ”LIBERIA: 300 Sierra Leonean
Refugees to be ‘naturalized’”, West Africa Democracy Radio, 18 June 2013.
41