Letter from the Co-Presidents
Citizenship, Authoritarianism, and the Paradox of Liberal Democracy
Alexandra Filindra,
University of Illinois
at Chicago
Sara Wallace Goodman,
University of California,
Irvine
Today, once again, we are witnessing the great paradox of liberal democracy, one that
Carl Popper was keenly aware of: the threat to open societies does not always come
from outside the gates, it often comes from within. Western liberal democracies rose
out of the ashes of World War II and led to the longest period of peace that the modern
world has known. It was those war experiences and the knowledge that millions of people died in the name of ethnic nationalism, communism, and fascism, that led to the establishment of open societies striving to be inclusive of the other and supportive of the
weak.
These days, we live in an era when more and more immigrants from all over the
world are seeking to share into the material and moral riches of the West, embracing
the political, social, and cultural values of liberal democracy. Often required by law, they
shed headscarves and native tongues along with other cultural and social practices and
beliefs. Data from multiple countries tell us that immigrants are net contributors to
Western economies (the story for refugees is more complicated given the conditions
under which they are admitted), they display lower levels of criminality, they are patriotic
(in the U.S. thousands have served in the military and have been welcomed to do so,
until recent efforts by the Trump administration to purge the ranks), and they are the
strongest hope for stemming the Western demographic crisis and the associated crisis
of the welfare state.
At the same time, a portion of the native-born population, those raised in the context of liberal ideals and institutions, feel so threatened by Spanish or Turkish or Arabic
spoken on the train platform and the supermarket line, by the chanting call of the muezzin, and the different color of skin of the people in their midst, that they become willing
to sacrifice liberal norms and institutions built with great sacrifice and over many decades. Ultra-nationalist, authoritarian leaders and parties have cropped up in almost
every Western democracy attacking liberal values and institutions, but promising protection of cultural homogeneity.
http://community.apsanet.org/migrationcitizenship/home
2