Voluntary renunciation. Some individuals formally renounce their citizenship, a voluntary act
to relinquish ties with their country of nationality. Individuals who renounce any other nationality become mono-citizens in the United States. For naturalized U.S. citizens in this situation, denaturalization would make them stateless.
Discrimination. Discrimination in nationality laws is one of the largest causes of statelessness.335
For example, members of minority ethnic or religious groups stripped of their nationality, or
women who lose their nationality upon marriage to a foreign spouse, are vulnerable to statelessness if they have naturalized as Americans and are subsequently denaturalized.
DENATIONALIZATION AND PROTECTION FROM STATELESSNESS
Temesgen Haile, an Ethiopian of Eritrean ethnicity, fled to the United States when the
Ethiopian government began arbitrarily expelling 75,000 persons of Eritrean ethnicity in
1998. He sought asylum based on his fear that he too would be stripped of his citizenship
by the Ethiopian authorities. His claim was denied by the immigration judge and the
Board of Immigration Appeals based on the conclusion that forced denationalization
without additional harm is not persecution. On appeal, the circuit court ruled that in some
circumstances forced denationalization could constitute persecution. “If Ethiopia
denationalized [him] because of his Eritrean ethnicity, it did so because of hostility to
Eritreans....To be deported to the country that made you stateless and continues to
consider you stateless is to be subjected to persecution.” (Haile v. Holder, 591 F.3d 572
(7th Cir. 2010)).
II. Denaturalization: A Radical Measure in the Hands of Zealots
79
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents