In addition to the high probability that denaturalization results in statelessness, there is also a
close correlation between the country of origin data from 2017-18 and President Trump’s
specific public attacks against these countries and their populations. The president has overtly
disparaged Mexicans,164 Haitians,165 Haiti,166 and Nigerians,167 all in connection with his
administration’s immigration policies.
Case disposition168
Of all 89 closed cases (36 civil and 53 criminal), the following outcomes obtained (as of
June 1, 2019):
4
Grand Total
6
3
0
Summary Judgment
7
0
Plea/Consent Settlement
0
2
0
Judgment on the Pleadings
Bench Trial
Against the
defendant
1
Jury Verdict
In favor of the
defendant
69
86
Of the cases reviewed, 142 defendants faced denaturalization (rather than attempt or procurement on behalf of another). Of these, 75 cases were concluded,169 and 72 individuals, or 96%,
were ordered denaturalized.170
Basic information on the profile of defendants
Defendants in denaturalization cases in 2017 and 2018 were 81% male, their average age was
between 50 and 51 years old, and they had an average date of naturalization of 2009 (10 years
ago, which is the statutory limit for bringing criminal denaturalization cases).171 Dates of
naturalization ranged between two and 24 years ago.
Procedural issues
Right to counsel. In civil cases during 2017-18, more than a quarter (25.76%) of defendants were
unrepresented. These include cases in which defendants had counsel for only a portion of the
proceedings, often at later stages such as the consideration of the government’s motion for
summary judgment or judgment on the pleadings. Unrepresented defendants lost in all closed
cases reviewed for this report.
II. Denaturalization: A Radical Measure in the Hands of Zealots
47
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents