Refusing Refusal
MIXED METHODS
Palestinians are being focused on because they constitute the largest group of
stateless people in Sweden. They represent complex realities of arriving from a
variety of contexts and previous countries of residence. Sweden has been chosen
as a case study because of its rapidly harshening migration politics in recent years.
The article has a multi-sided approach. A qualitative text analysis has been
applied to investigate altogether 15 decisions on asylum in the first instance. These
were sourced from: the SMA, which have been made available to me by claimants
themselves, 53 the Swedish Utlänningslagen (‘Aliens Act’), 54 official enquiries,
temporary laws, five decisions of the Courts of Migration and legal decisions of
the SMA. 55 The analysis has interpreted the formulation of different techniques of
the regime and how those are manifested in the documents.
Interpretations of narratives 56 collected through conversations with stateless
Palestinians primarily in Gothenburg, but also Malmö, Stockholm and smaller
towns in the Western Region of Sweden, constitute a major part of the
methodological design. Interviews are ethically sensitive and narrators have been
given pseudonyms. As the asylum process is contingent on frequent questioning
in official institutions resembling interrogation procedures, underlining
vulnerabilities and that one’s story is constantly disputed or challenged. The
method used emphasises a story-focused avenue in order to let people
communicate their stories and experiences in their own words rather than through
me conducting ‘interviews’. There is a hunt for migrant stories by different
authorities, researchers, humanitarian organisations, NGOs and journalists and,
most of the time, sharing those stories does not mean change for migrants.
Therefore, ethical questions of risks of exploitation are at the fore. Individuals
have told me their stories of the asylum process, how they actually managed
different stages and aspects of the process and how they acted in order to influence
their futures. Confidence has been important and has been built with the
Palestinian community in Sweden through earlier studies and through personal
networks. Throughout the article, some of these stories will be fleshed out in some
detail. These stories were selected as they stand out as important contributions in
the sense that they illustrate both conduct and counter-conduct.
The narratives are built on 12 deep interviews with men, arriving between 2007
and 2019. Men often arrive earlier than their families and wait for them to arrive
later, as well as being more actively engaged in protest activities. Two have been
interviewed through follow-ups with up to four years in-between. All interviewees
have been offered the opportunity to read the transcripts of their interviews and
have been able to revise those transcripts. 11 additional shorter conversations have
been held with men and women alike, in family homes, at offices/workplaces or
in relation to protest activities taking place in Gothenburg in the Spring of 2020.
Those conversations provided additional information but were not organised as
53
54
55
56
In referring to documents, code initials have been given to the claimants who appear in the
texts and dates have not been revealed.
Utlänningslagen [Aliens Act] (29 September 2005) Svensk författningssamling 2005:716
(Sweden) (‘Aliens Act’).
Rättsliga ställningstaganden. These do not have the status of legal decisions.
See Marita Eastmond, ‘Stories as Lived Experiences: Narratives in Forced Migration
Research’ (2007) 20(2) Journal of Refugee Studies 248; Catherine K Riessmann, Narrative
Methods for the Human Sciences (Sage Publications 2008).
273