A. T HE R IGHT TO NAT IONALIT Y FOR EV E RY INDIV IDUAL
process. Articles 20 and 22 reiterate principles of natural justice
when laying down criminal procedural rights.
Both the FT and the NRC processes in Assam shall be
examined for procedural guarantees. FTs are quasi-judicial
authorities created by the Central Government under the
Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964, in exercise of its powers
under Section 3 of the Foreigners Act.43 They are the forums
where accused individuals must prove their Indian nationality.
There are two mechanisms through which cases are referred to
FTs. First, through the Assam Border Police, which is empowered
to serve notice to suspected foreigners. Secondly, the Election
Commission of India in 1997 conducted a large scale revision of
electoral rolls and labelled several thousands of persons as
‘doubtful’ voters, whose cases are adjudicated before FTs as well.
Two Foreigners (Tribunals) Amendment Orders, passed in 2013
and 2019, further expanded the powers of FTs, including the
power to detain persons and grant bail.
The NRC exercise in Assam followed the Citizenship Act,
1955 and the Citizenship Rules, 2003.44 It demanded two sets of
documents from every individual: the first set to identify a legacy
person with whom the applicant claims descent, and the second
to establish linkage between the applicant and the legacy
person.45 Decades of poor recordkeeping and irregular
digitisation coupled with poverty and illiteracy led to a large
number of exclusions from the NRC, despite many of these
applicants knowing no home other than Assam. Those excluded
can eventually file their appeals before FTs as well.
Neither the Foreigners Act nor the three subsequent
orders lay down a clear, consistent, comprehensive, and predetermined procedure applicable to FTs. These tribunals instead
43 The Foreigners Act, 1946 empowers the Central Government to regulate the entry and presence of
foreigners in Indian territory.
44 The Citizenship Act, 1955, s. 6A; The Citizenship (Registration of Citizens and Issue of National
Identity Cards) Rules, 2003, rule 4A and Schedule.
45 Government of Assam, ‘What are the admissible documents?’ <http://nrcassam.nic.in/admindocuments.html> accessed 1 July 2020.
chapter i • status
53
SECTION I.A.3.1