T H E G L O B A L S TAT E O F C I T I Z E N S H I P
D I D YO U K N OW ?
Why the US has territorial
birthright citizenship
home nations in order to strengthen their own statehood. However, universal birthright citizenship was
not established in the US until after the Civil War. In
the infamous Dred Scott case of 1857, the Supreme
Court ruled that no Black person could ever be a US
citizen. It took the Fourteenth Amendment of 1868
to establish that ‘[a]ll persons born or naturalised
in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction
thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the
State wherein they reside.’ Among his first actions
as reinstalled president, Donald Trump issued a 20
January 2025 executive order purporting to roll back
territorial birthright citizenship in the United States.
Most citizenship scholars view this as unconstitutional.
While some think that the US is the only country
with birthright citizenship, unconditional territorial
birthright citizenship is common throughout North
and South America. For the US and Canada, this
is inherited from English common law going back
to the famous Calvin’s case of 1608. Calvin’s Case
is ‘the earliest, most influential theoretical articulation by an English court of what came to be the
common-law rule that a person’s status was vested
at birth and based upon place of birth’. In most of
South America, the legacy of ius soli goes back to the
Spanish 1812 Cádiz Constitution.
Throughout the Americas, territorial birthright
served a useful purpose because former colonial territories needed to break immigrants’ links with their
See also this Vox.com explainer video about why the
US has birthright citizenship.
1.3 TERRITORIAL BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP AROUND THE WORLD
Type of territorial bir thright citizenship principle (excl provisions for foundlings and those who would other wise
be stateless) | 191 countries | 2024
Territorial birthright citizenship
Unconditional
Parental residence
or birth restriction
Source: GLOBALCIT Citizenship Law Dataset, v3, mode A02
7
Gender or group
restriction
No provision