IMP LEMENTATIO N
IN DE P T H
BEST INTERESTS
OF THE CHILD
While there is no precise
definition of the term “best
interests of the child,” it broadly
describes the well-being of
a child. Such well-being is
determined by a variety of
individual circumstances, such
as the age, the level of maturity
of the child, the presence or
absence of parents, the child’s
environment and experiences.
The Convention on the Rights
of the Child requires that “the
best interests of the child shall
be a primary consideration in all
actions affecting children.”
“While it is always no fault of
their own, stateless children
often inherit an uncertain future.
For instance, they might fail to
benefit from protections and
constitutional rights granted by
the State. These include difficulty
to travel freely, difficulty in
accessing justice procedures when
necessary, as well as the challenge
of finding oneself in a legal limbo
vulnerable to expulsion from
their home country. Statelessness
is particularly devastating to
children in the realisation of their
socio-economic rights such as
access to health care, and access
to education. In sum, being
stateless as a child is generally
antithesis to the best interests of
children.”
African Committee on the Rights
and Welfare of the Child, Children
of Nubian descent in Kenya v.
Kenya (2011)
84
|
must make sure to protect clients’ personal information, and should
take identifying details out of any reports. Databases and filing systems
should be secure and all procedures compliant with data protection laws.
Paralegals who work with children should receive special training,
which includes training on how to determine the best interests of the
child. Generally, service to children involves gaining access to a birth
certificate in order to secure other essential rights such as education, a
name, and a nationality.
Sometimes the steps involved in registering a birth can put someone else
in danger. For example, a child might only be able to be registered if the
parents’ marriage is registered. If one of the parents abuses the other,
marriage registration may put the victim at risk. A couple with mixed
ethnic or religious backgrounds may also be at risk from the state or their
communities if they register their marriage. Paralegals must factor in the best
interests of the child, and of all those involved, when advising on such cases.
Integrity
Paralegals should be held to the highest standards in all they do. This
requires thorough training, effective supervision and feedback, and
adequate support materials, in order to ensure all information they share
is accurate and complete. It is also important to obey any local laws
about what paralegals can and cannot do. If you refer clients to any
organizations or service-providers or receive referrals from them, you
should consider whether they meet a high standard as well. Encourage
any such organizations that do not have their own ethical charter or code
of conduct to adopt one.
ee 9.2 Information Sharing for more guidelines on the scope of
S
advice-giving by paralegals.
Impartiality
Your project must serve people equally regardless of who they know.
Community-based paralegals are particularly vulnerable to accusations
that they favored their own contacts. Establish clear guidelines regarding
how to prioritize resources, such as “first come, first served,” or putting
individuals with specific vulnerabilities first. Paralegals should be
aware that monitoring and evaluation of their activities will likely cover
community perceptions of their fairness. Establish practices to address
the problem if paralegals favor their personal contacts.
Fraud
Fraud is a particular challenge in access to documentation work. Faced
with unreasonable laws, people might make a reasonable decision to use
a fraudulent document. Other might not know they have fake documents
from unscrupulous agents (often called “brokers”) who sell them. Using a
A C O M M U N I T Y- B A S E D P R A C T I T I O N E R ’ S G U I D E : D O C U M E N T I N G C I T I Z E N S H I P A N D OT H E R F O R M S O F L E G A L I D E N T I T Y
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents