4, ADDRESSING STATELESSNESS THROUGH THE RIGHTS TO EQUALITY
AND NON-DISCRIMINATION
statelessness is the result of the denial of nationality which may be
arbitrary under international law.® The relevance of discrimination
as a key element of each of these causes of statelessness is often
underestimated.’
Most clearly, statelessness may result from discriminatory laws. As
stated above,
27 countries
continue
to have
nationality laws which
discriminate between men and women in determining who can confer
their nationality on their children. Where a directly sex discriminatory
law prevents a mother from conferring her nationality on her child, that
child may be at risk of statelessness if they are also unable to acquire
nationality from their father (e.g. where he himself is stateless, he is
deceased or his identity is unknown, he cannot confer his nationality
on his children due to conflict of laws or he refuses to do so).?° For
example, in Nepal, despite much advocacy, the recent enactment
of a new Constitution has not resulted in the removal of gender
discrimination from the country’s nationality laws.'? Accordingly, it
remains the case that children born in Nepal to a Nepali mother and a
father whose identity is unknown, who is deceased or has deserted the
family, who is a foreigner or who refuses to acknowledge
may become stateless.’* Despite a recent increase in
reform of the laws of these 27 countries, spearheaded
Campaign for Equal Nationality Rights and other actors,
of this cause of statelessness remains some way off.’°
8
’
10
See for example, various UN Secretary General reports on arbitrary deprivation
of nationality: A/HRC/31/29; A/HRC/25/28; A/HRC/23/23; A/HRC/19/43
etc; and various UN Human Rights Council Resolutions on the arbitrary
deprivation of nationality: Resolution 32/5 (2016); 26/14 (2014); 20/05
(2012) etc.
The authors explored this link in an earlier article: A. de Chickera and J.
Whiteman, “Discrimination and the human security of stateless people”,
Forced Migration Review 2014, Issue 46, p. 56. This article has formed the
starting point for the analysis which follows.
See UNHCR, Global Action Plan, supra n3, p. 12.
"Constitution of the Kingdom of Nepal 2015, Section 11, Part 2.
1!
3
his paternity
the calls for
by the Global
the abolition
For testimonies from individuals affected by the discriminatory laws in Nepal
see Equal Rights Trust, My Children’s Future, supra n2.
For more information about the campaign and efforts for reform in the twenty
seven countries see, Global Campaign for Equal Nationality Rights, www.
equalnationalityrights.org. Both ERT and ISI are steering committee members
of the campaign and both authors serve on the committee.
102