SOLVING STATELESSNESS
negative stereotypes are not addressed in this section, these are also
important strategies which might be pursued.
4.1 Litigation
The courts are often a valuable tool in vindicating the equal rights
of stateless people, including their right to a nationality. Since
governments are often unwilling to engage with this issue, the courts
are particularly important and there is much that can be done by
lawyers adopting the equality framework in litigation. In addition
to holding governments to account for their failure to uphold the
rights of stateless people, courts can provide remedies to victims of
discrimination. In some jurisdictions, the powers of courts are not
insignificant. The Declaration of Principles on Equality requires that
sanctions for breach of the right to equality be “effective, proportionate
and dissuasive” (Principle 22). In numerous States, courts are able to
award remedies not only to compensate the victim but also to address
the systemic problem which may have contributed to the violation.°?
It is important to note, before extolling the virtues of the court as a
tool for solving statelessness, that individual access to justice for the
vindication of rights is a critical component of the State’s obligation to
respect, protect and fulfil the rights to equality and non-discrimination
of the individual. If, as is often the case, stateless people do not have
recourse to the courts, either due to their own financial limitations, the
lack of an adequate judicial system or even questions regarding their
standing before the courts, it is clear that there will be difficulties in
ensuring that this tool is available. In such situations lawyers might
argue that unequal access to justice is itself a matter of unlawful
discrimination against stateless people. The ICCPR obligation to
protect equality before the law (Article 14) is an obligation to ensure
access to justice for all people, including the stateless.
4,1,1, Using equality law to ensure socio-economic rights
While international human rights law protects the rights of all people
to enjoyment of socio-economic rights through the International
Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, these rights have
°°
For a more in depth discussion see, Equal Rights Trust, Economic and Social
Rights in the Courtroom, 2012, p. 94.
119