THREATS TO THE INTER-AMERICAN
HUMAN RIGHTS SYSTEM
Despite the extent of the region’s human
rights challenges, the Inter-American
Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) –
critical to defend and promote human rights
as well as ensure access to justice for victims
who were unable to do so in their own
countries – was affected by a financial crisis
for most of the year. This was caused by an
insufficient allocation of resources by
member states of the Organization of
American States (OAS) – a striking
demonstration of states’ lack of political will to
promote and protect human rights both
within and beyond their territories.
In May, the IACHR said it faced the worst
financial crisis in its history. There was a real
danger that progress made by the IACHR in
confronting gross human rights violations and
structural discrimination would be weakened
– precisely when the IACHR needed to play a
more vigorous role in ensuring states uphold
their obligations under international human
rights law.
With an annual budget of US$8 million,
the inter-American human rights system
remained the world’s poorest human rights
system, with fewer resources than its
corresponding entities in Africa (US$13
million) and Europe (about US$104.5
million).
Although additional funding was eventually
received to complement the IACHR income,
there were concerns that the political crisis
would continue unless states allocated
adequate funding to the institution and cooperated with it, regardless of how critical it
was of countries’ human rights record.
There were more specific failures to
support the IACHR too. Mexico’s government
sought to obstruct its work on the Ayotzinapa
case – in which 43 students were forcibly
disappeared after being arrested by police in
2014. Despite the authorities’ claim that the
students were kidnapped by a criminal gang,
and their remains burned and thrown in a
dumpster, a group of IACHR-appointed
experts concluded that it was scientifically
Amnesty International Report 2016/17
impossible for that many bodies to have been
burned in the conditions claimed. In
November, the IACHR launched a special
mechanism to follow up on the experts’
recommendations, but appropriate support
from the authorities was difficult to
guarantee.
REFUGEES, MIGRANTS AND STATELESS
PEOPLE
Central America was the source of a rapidly
worsening refugee crisis. Relentless violence
in this often forgotten part of the world
continued to cause a surge in asylum
applications from Central American citizens
in Mexico, the USA and other countries,
reaching levels not seen since most of the
region’s armed conflicts ended decades ago.
Hundreds of thousands of people travelled
through Mexico either to seek asylum there,
or to continue to the USA. Many were
detained in harsh conditions, killed,
abducted or faced extortion by criminal
gangs who often operated in collusion with
the authorities. Large numbers of
unaccompanied children and adolescents
were particularly affected by human rights
abuses; women and girls were at serious risk
of sexual violence and human trafficking.
Despite overwhelming evidence that many
asylum-seekers were at risk of extreme
violence should they not be granted asylum,
deportations from Mexico and the USA
remained steady. Many people were forcibly
returned back to the life-threatening
situations they were fleeing in the first place;
some were allegedly killed by gangs after
being deported.
Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador
fuelled this deepening crisis by failing to
protect people from violence and to set up a
comprehensive protection plan for people
who were deported from countries such as
Mexico and the USA.
Yet, rather than taking responsibility for
their role in the crisis, the governments
concerned focused only on the human rights
abuses that people suffered while travelling
through Mexico to the USA. They also falsely
argued that most people were fleeing out of
27
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents