is not exceptional, but rather points to a state policy with both political and
discriminatory underpinnings.
Furthermore, the ‘unrecognized’ designation disqualifies villages from
receiving infrastructure development and service provision. The interviewee
detailed how his children had left their original village, al-Araqib, to settle
in other areas to access essential services and better work opportunities.
The denial of services, such as water, sanitation or electricity resulting from
its ‘unrecognized’ status, severely affects the right to an adequate standard
of living. This deprivation of essential services is forcing Bedouins out of
the village in search of better living conditions. In addition, Israeli policies
of displacement implemented in al-Araqib harm the Bedouin social fabric
by impacting family or tribe unity, which is an essential component of
their culture. The ongoing displacement is affecting the right to family life
of the inhabitants of the village, including having and maintaining family
relationships.140
The numerous demolition operations have also imposed harsh consequences
on the population’s wellbeing, safety and security. People including children
and elders remained homeless and without shelter for months at a time,
violating their right to adequate housing. During these demolition operations,
the population of al-Araqib was subjected to excessive use of force given the
extent of police and military forces present, and the violence used against
the inhabitants. The ongoing demolitions have severely affected the Bedouin
lifestyle, grounded in agriculture and husbandry; accordingly, families’
financial situations have worsened. Further worsening the living conditions
of Bedouins, the ILA sprayed chemicals on the lands of al-Araqib seriously
affecting the health of its inhabitants, and may even be directly responsible
for a number of deaths. This could amount to grave violations of both the
right to health and the right to life.
Finally, the people of al-Araqib are subjected to significant economic
burdens, as illustrated by the absence of any form of compensation allocated
for the loss of the livestock and crops due to chemical treatments, home
demolitions, plus Israeli-imposed fines. Article 2 of the ICCPR provides for an
adequate remedy for the violation of the right to property that Israel denies
to the residents of al-Araqib, by requiring payment for the demolition of their
own homes and properties. Israel is therefore responsible for impoverishing
al-Araqib Bedouins by denying them access to their farm lands, in violation
140 UN General Assembly, Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 10 December 1948, 217 A (III), art.
16, available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/3ae6b3712c.html [accessed 28 September 2017]
[hereinafter UDHR].
50
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents