Legal Identity and Housing, Land and Property Rights of Syrian Refugees from a Durable Solutions Perspective
Challenges and Opportunities
Box 4:
Challenges related to missing persons
Refugee families with missing relatives face increased legal
protection challenges, attributed to several factors, including: a
reluctance to approach Syrian authorities to report or even ask about
the missing, a fear of being arrested during the process, a lack of
awareness of the reporting mechanisms, a lack of required identity
documents and evidence to prove someone is missing, and the risk of
financial extortion by intermediaries. The status of missing persons
and/or the lack of proof of death affects the legal and social safety of
the family, in particular of wives who are unable to remarry, obtain
child custody, and enjoy their inheritance rights, and of children who
are unable to demonstrate their legal connection with their fathers,
resulting in a heightened risk of statelessness.
3.1.2 Coping mechanisms & risks
I wanted to get a birth
“certificate
for my child, but here
in Jordan you cannot get a birth
certificate for a newborn unless
you have a marriage contract…
that’s why I had to get a falsified
marriage contract.
103
“
Syrian refugee in Jordan
Photo: NRC
When unable to access the civil
documentation they need, refugees may
resort to coping mechanisms that can
put them at further risk, such as engaging
intermediaries, or travelling to Syria to access
or obtain documents. Acting, or making
decisions based on misinformation can also
contribute to increased risks for refugees. The
use of fraudulent Syrian and host country
documents has emerged as both a coping
strategy and an unwanted consequence for
some refugees. Refugees unable to issue,
replace, or update documents through
adequate legal and administrative procedures
may resort to obtaining or using fraudulent
documents. Refugees can also inadvertently
end up with fraudulent documents by ‘acting
outside’ of the prescribed processes to obtain
or update documentation. It is often unclear
whether a document obtained through an
intermediary has been validly issued by
authorities or not.
The type and level of documentation that
refugees possess and particular gender
issues were identified as driving factors for
refugees who obtained or used fraudulent
documents.103 In the context of child
marriages, spouses may also resort to the
use of false documentation to register
their children. Refugees who possess and
use fraudulent documents face significant
short- and long-term consequences that can
complicate their legal status, risk criminal
penalties for themselves and family members
and, as such, present barriers to accessing
durable solutions.104 Losing money and
original documents, imprisonment, fines,
and, in extreme cases, deportation were
reported. Refugees who are unaware their
documents are fraudulent are at risk of
legal prosecution when presenting these
documents to an authority.
104
KII for joint UNHCR/NRC regional
research, 2020. Syrian stateless
Kurds, refugee children born in host
countries who have a fraudulent
birth certificate or have been falsely
registered under the name of
different parents and Palestinian
refugees from Syria were identified
as being particularly vulnerable and
potentially reliant on fraudulent
documents. For male refugees,
the fear of compulsory military
conscription or the perception of
being affiliated with an opposition
group were key driving factors
behind obtaining fraudulent
documentation. Female refugees
were commonly motivated to use
fraudulent documents to meet
an important need like accessing
healthcare during pregnancy and
childbirth or claiming guardianship.
Forgery and falsification of
documents are considered a crime
under Syrian, Iraqi, Jordanian, and
Lebanese laws. The laws make a
common and critical distinction
between the use of a forged
document and the act of forgery.
The forgery of official documents,
including civil documents (e.g.,
birth certificates) and judicial/
administrative documents, is
considered a felony, whereas the
issuance of false certified documents
(e.g., birth notifications) by qualified
persons, including health workers,
lawyers, mukhtars, religious figures
and judicial police, is classified as a
misdemeanour.
17