SUB-REGIONAL OVERVIEW: SOUTH ASIA
in border regions (including the Chakma, Hjong
and Kutchi communities) and former Kashmiri
militants.247 Ethnic minority groups in Nepal
include Dalit and Madheshi communities, who
face issues of accessing citizenship and identity
documents, are also at risk of statelessness.248
Undetermined Nationalities
In 2019 India’s National Register of Citizens
in Assam excluded over 1.9 million Assamese,
leaving them labelled as foreigners or ‘D voters’
and the validation of their citizenship at the hands
of the foreigners’ tribunals.249 As of December
2021, 143,466 persons were declared foreigners
by the foreigners’ tribunals and 121,598 persons
were declared as Indian citizens. Another 123,829
cases remain pending before the tribunals.250
UNHCR has noted that “various studies estimate
that a large number of individuals lack citizenship
certificates in Nepal. While these individuals
are not necessarily stateless, UNHCR has been
working closely with the Government of Nepal
and partners to address this situation.”251 In 2016
the Forum for Women, Law and Development
projected that by 2021 as many as 6.7 million
people would be without citizenship certificates.252
In Pakistan, Ethnic Bihari communities also hold
an uncertain status with limited information
available on their citizenship status. The
FIGURE 13
SUB-REGIONAL OVERVIEW: SOUTH ASIA
community largely comprises of persons
repatriated to Pakistan following Bangladeshi
independence (and their descendants), some of
whom hold passports and documentation, yet
continue to face discrimination and exclusion.253
2017.254 Most of the more than 900,000 Rohingya
refugees in Bangladesh reside within refugee
camps in Cox’s Bazaar, and face limited access to
health and social services, education and living in
conditions that have been condemned by residents,
international organisations and NGOs.255
Stateless Refugees
The true scale of the Rohingya refugee population
in South Asia is estimated to be thousands higher
than reported figures. Human Rights Watch has
estimated that Rohingyas registered with UNHCR
in India (20,154) represent half of the total
population of 40,000 Rohingya refugees in the
country.256 A recent statement by a spokesperson
for the Pakistani Foreign Office suggested that
as many as 400,000 Rohingya refugees may be in
Pakistan (compared to the reported 47).257
The entire reported stateless population in South
Asia are stateless refugees. While UNHCR
has noted that the reported stateless refugee
populations in India (20,154) and Nepal (465) are
Rohingya refugees, this is not explicitly stated for
the other countries in the sub-region. There has
been an extensive focus on Rohingya in Bangladesh
by UN bodies, academics and NGOs, specifically
since the mass displacement which occurred in
FIGURE 14
Other groups of refugees affected by statelessness
include as many as 73,404 Tibetan refugees and
more than 92,000 Sri Lankan refugees in India.258
6,365 Bhutanese Lhostshampa refugees are in
Nepal, many of whom are stateless.259
Reported Stateless and Stateless Refugee
Population in South Asia
Reported Stateless Population
Other Populations of Note
Reported Stateless Refugees
1500000
1200000
900000
National Register of Citizens- India
600000
INRC Assam excluded over 1.9 million Assamese,
leaving them labelled as foreigners or ‘D voters’ and
the validation of their citizenship
Foreigners
300000
143,466
Times of India (Feb 2022)
Srilanka
Pakistan
Nepal
Maldives
123,829
India
Pending
Bhutan
121,598
Bangladesh
Indian citizens
Afghanistan
0
It is important to note two population groups
within South Asia who have had their stateless
status ‘solved’ in recent decades yet continue
to face discrimination and social exclusion. The
Urdu-speaking (Bihari) community have resided
in Bangladesh since independence,260 yet were
only recognised as citizens from the early 2000s.
Despite the recognition, the 300,000 people of
the Urdu-speaking community continue to face
discrimination and marginalisation through the
denial of passports, physical isolation in refugeelike camps and denial of services.261 The granting of
citizenship to the ‘Hill Country’ (or ‘Up-Country’)
Tamil population in Sri Lanka in 2003, who had
been deprived of citizenship since 1948, has
both been held up as a success story of ‘solving’
statelessness and analysed for the continuing
discrimination faced by the population group
despite their citizenship status being resolved.262
The Urdu-speaking (Bihari) community
have resided in Bangladesh since independence, yet were only recognised as
citizens from the early 2000s. Despite
the recognition, the 300,000 people of
the Urdu-speaking community continue
to face discrimination and marginalisation through the denial of passports,
physical isolation in refugee-like camps
and denial of services.
Availability of data
Underreporting is present in all states in the South
Asia sub-region, where Afghanistan, Bhutan, and
the Maldives, reported no stateless populations
and all other states in the sub-region did not report
numbers for in situ stateless populations. UNHCR
recognizes this underreporting and notes the
specific known populations in all states in the subregion apart from the Maldives that are missing
from their reported figures.263 Further, the only
reported stateless population is categorized as
stateless refugees, which excludes other existing
stateless populations in the sub-region. Even
among this group underreporting is present with
the true scale of the Rohingya population across
the sub-region estimated to be much higher than
reported figures.
Causes of statelessness
Discriminatory laws
Restrictions on the basis of ethnicity
As outlined in the Southeast Asia chapters, the
statelessness of the Rohingya community present
across the South Asia sub-region is largely
caused by ethnic discrimination embedded in the
citizenship laws of Myanmar.264 Ethnic minority
groups including the Mosuli and Jogi (or ‘Magat’)
communities who have lived semi-nomadic
48
49
STATELESSNESS ENCYCLOPEDIA ASIA PACIFIC
REPORT 2023