most instances the provision in question should apply to all refugees [stateless persons]
whose presence in the territory was lawful, if it applied also to other aliens in the same
circumstances. Wherever higher requirements were made the Committee used the expression
“lawfully staying.”237
For further clarity the Handbook on Protection of Stateless Persons states:
For stateless persons to be “lawfully in” a State party, their presence in the country needs to
be authorized by the State. The concept encompasses both presence which is explicitly
sanctioned and also that which is known and not prohibited, taking into account all personal
circumstances of the individual. The duration of presence can be temporary…As confirmed
by the drafting history of the Convention, applicants for statelessness status who enter into a
determination procedure are therefore “lawfully in” in the territory of a State party. By
contrast, an individual who has no immigration status in the country and declines the
opportunity to enter a statelessness determination procedure is not “lawfully in” the
country.238
In sum, “lawfully in their territory” means those who are physically present in the territory,
provided that their presence is not unlawful, and includes short-time visitors and even persons
merely travelling through the country.239
Article 18 further requires that stateless persons fulfill the conditions necessary for the exercise
of the self-employment activity in question, such as specific qualifications, licences or
concessions.240 For stateless persons not residing in the country in which they want to engage in
self-employment, or where they wish to establish commercial or industrial companies, are not
within the scope of Article 18, instead Article 7(1) of the 1954 Convention applies.241
II.
Canadian Legal Framework
As discussed in Article 17, all foreign nationals require a valid work permit to work in Canada. 242
This also applies to foreign nationals who wish to be self-employed and establish their own
business. For stateless persons in Canada wishing to establish their own business there are a few
options to obtain authorization to work in Canada.
a. Economic Classes – Permanent Resident Status
Some programs allow a foreign national in Canada to apply for permanent residence status as
Robinson Commentary to the 1954 Convention, supra note 11 at 40.
Handbook on Protection of Stateless Persons, supra note 12 at para. 135.
239
UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), Commentary of the Refugee Convention 1951 (Articles 2-11,
13-37), October 1997, at 45, available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/4785ee9d2.html [Atle Grahl-Madsen 1951
Commentary]
240
1951 Convention travaux préparatoires, supra note 61 at 109; and Robinson Commentary to the 1954
Convention, supra note note 11 at 40.
241
Robinson Commentary to the 1954 Convention, ibid., at 39.
242
IRPR, supra note 21 at s. 186.
237
238
49
49