The Maltese Falcon, or: my Porsche
for a Passport!
Jelena Džankić
‘We didn’t exactly believe your story, Miss O’Shaughnessy. We believed
your 200 dollars. I mean, you paid us more than if you had been telling us
the truth, and enough more to make it all right.’ These were the words of
Sam Spade played by Humphrey Bogart in the 1941 film ‘The Maltese
Falcon’. Malta’s recent amendments to the Citizenship Act suggest that for
the country’s policymakers the amount of € 650,000 is just enough ‘to make
it all right’ for investors to purchase the Maltese and by extension the
European Union (EU) citizenship. But is cash-for-passport really ‘all right’,
and does it affect the value of citizenship?
Magni Berton suggests in his contribution to this Forum that what is
wrong with the Maltese law is that ordinary naturalisation is too difficult and
discretionary. Indeed, for most applicants, meeting the criteria for ordinary
naturalisation takes a long time and a lot of effort. During the years of residence that the applicants spend in their country of destination they make that
country the focal point of their lives: they learn its language, its customs and
establish social links with other citizens living there. Their claim to citizenship of that country is based – following Shachar – on ius nexi. Hence the
integration of such individuals is of high value for citizenship as a public
good, as a network of communal contributions and responsibilities, as
shared love for the country.
Yet, Magni Berton claims that the rich may as well love the destination
country and that money may merely be an instrument for facilitating their
access to citizenship. Instead of a ‘human investment’, which would entail
time, establishment of social links, and acquisition of language skills, the
wealthy can make a monetary contribution. However, as highlighted in other
contributions to this debate, the rich usually do not spend much time in their
destination countries. Rather, as Spiro noted, they mostly use the opportunities provided to them by virtue of possessing its passport. Now, what is love
in this context? The one who truly loves is willing to wait and invest time
and effort. Otherwise, we would not speak about love. Offering money in
© The Author(s) 2018
R. Bauböck (ed.), Debating Transformations of National Citizenship,
IMISCOE Research Series,
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-92719-0_7
33