Court112. The issue was further considered by the Supreme Administrative Court which decided
that the nationality of the children should be confirmed113.
4.3.2 Avoidance of statelessness in the context of deprivation and loss of nationality
Polish law does not allow for the deprivation of Polish nationality.114 There are certain situations,
however, which can result in a loss of nationality, leading to a risk of statelessness. Article
34(2) of the Polish Constitution states that the only way of losing Polish nationality is by an act
of renunciation. The procedure of renunciation is described in the Act on Polish Citizenship.
According to this Act, a person willing to renounce Polish nationality must submit an appropriate
declaration which takes effect only after the President of the Republic of Poland gives his consent
to this renunciation. The relevant provisions do not include an explicit guarantee that would
prohibit nationality loss in case it would result in statelessness. However, such a guarantee can
be interpreted from the requirement of submitting a document proving possession of another
nationality or a promise of such nationality together with the application to the President. If the
person willing to renounce Polish nationality cannot provide such documents, his or her motion
will not be processed. Interestingly, however, there is no explicit requirement to include such
documentation in relation to children included in the application. Therefore, there may be cases
where the parent renounces Polish nationality to acquire a nationality of another state and his
or her children’s Polish nationality is lost but the new state does not grant its nationality to those
children. Furthermore, a promise of nationality is not a guarantee that one will not end up stateless.
Polish law, therefore, does not fully comply with Article 6 of the 1961 Convention according to
which, in case the loss of nationality of a parent results in the loss of nationality of the child, such
loss should be conditional upon the child’s possession or acquisition of another nationality. The Act
on Polish Citizenship should, thus, be amended to include a specific guarantee regarding children in
the renunciation procedure.
There are also other ways in which Polish nationality can be lost. In the case of foreigners who were
recognized as Polish nationals by a decision of a Voivod, such a decision can be invalidated if, for
example, fraud was committed at the time of the application. The general rules of administrative
procedure apply (for example, Article 156(1)(2) of the Code of Administrative Procedure, which
stipulates that a decision can be invalidated if it was issued without the legal basis and in flagrant
violation of the law) and there is no special guarantee against statelessness. These provisions are
in compliance with the 1961 Convention according to which a Contracting State may deprive
a person of its nationality, even if such deprivation would render him or her stateless, if the
nationality has been obtained by misrepresentation or fraud.115 There have been cases in which
decisions confirming Polish nationality were invalidated on the basis of Article 156(1)(2) of the
Code of Administrative Procedure. The decision confirming Polish nationality is a declaratory act
and its invalidation has serious practical consequences for a person. It also puts a person at risk
of statelessness because there is no special guarantee in the Code of Administrative Procedure
against statelessness.
44
112
Case files no. IV SA/Wa 3680/15; IV SA/Wa 3681/15; IV SA/Wa 3682/15; IV SA/Wa 3683/15.
113
Case files no. II OSK 1868/16, II OSK 1869/16, II OSK 1870/16, II OSK 1871/16
114
See Art. 34(2) of the Polish Constitution and Art. 46 of the Law on Citizenship.
115
Art. 8(2)(b) of the 1961 Convention.
MAPPING STATELESSNESS IN POLAND