Human Rights Brief, Vol. 24, Iss. 2 [2020], Art. 5 353 :&%+*1.2 2%1*)&%)+&#)$1X(.&$%(&2J28&$%(&34E@&J(/6-((& 2"*A(*$1"*8&)*.&$%(&2=<?xK&<%"6-%&2%1*)&%)+&*"$& #)$1X(.&$%(&O22wJ8&)+&)&+1-*)$"#B8&1$&+$199&%)+&$%(& ",91-)$1"*&$"&)0$&1*&-"".&/)1$%&)*.&*"$&$"&6*.(#71*(& $%(&D6#D"+(&"/&$%(&O22wJ?xN&O*&)..1$1"*8&2%1*)Z+& !)$1"*)91$B&P);&0"7D91(+&;1$%&$%(&D#1*01D9(&)-)1*+$& +$)$(9(++*(++&1*&$%(&2J28&$%(&O22wJ8&)*.&$%(& 34E@&J(/6-((&2"*A(*$1"*?&!"*($%(9(++8&2%1*)Z+& #(/"69(7(*$&D"910B&D#"769-)$(.&,B&$%(&2%1*)C !"#$%&'"#()&w#"$"0"9&)*.&1$+&=.71*1+$#)$1A(&P);& $";)#.&!"#$%&'"#()*&.(/(0$"#+&.1#(0$9B&A1"9)$(+& $%(&34E@&J(/6-((&2"*A(*$1"*&)*.&$%(&2=<?&2%1*)Z+& #(/"69(7(*$&D"910B&)9+"&6*.(#71*(+&$%(&O22wJZ+& D6#D"+(&"/&6D%"9.1*-&,)+10&%67)*&#1-%$+8&;%10%& 1*096.(&0%19.#(*Z+&#1-%$&$"&*)$1"*)91$B? "B#!"8C1+*0%+'$2 SQ$)$(9(++&D(#+"*+&)#(&(R096.(.&/#"7&(A(#B&/)0($&"/& +"01($B&)*.&)#(&"|(*&)7"*-&$%(&7"+$&A69*(#),9(& )*.&7)#-1*)91V(.&1*&+"01($B?Yx4&L(/(0$"#+Z&0%19.#(*& 0)**"$&(*#"99&1*&+0%""9&.(+D1$(&2%1*)Z+&2"7D69+"#B& [.60)$1"*&9);&,(0)6+(&$%(B&%)A(&*"&)00(++&$"&)& +&S2&?@5&>)*B&.(/(0$"#+Z&0%19.#(*&;%"&."&",$)1*&)& +&S2&&)*.&*)$1"*)91$B&."&+"&,(0)6+(&"/&$%(1#&7"$%(#Z+& #(/"69(7(*$?&<"&1996+$#)$(&$%(&$"99&$%1+&D"910B&0)*& $):(&"*&)&0%19.8&)&+1RCB()#C"9.&-1#9&;%"&91A(+&;1$%&%(#& 2%1*(+(&/)$%(#&)*.&-#)*.D)#(*$+&)*.&%)+&",$)1*(.&)& +&S2&$S+)1.&?&?&?&$%)$&%(#&7"$%(#&%).&-"*(&$"&$%(&D"910(& +$)$1"*&)*.&*(A(#&#($6#*(.?Y&<%1+&-1#9Z+&!"#$%&'"#()*& 7"$%(#&;)+&)##(+$(.&)*.&#(D)$#1)$(.&1*&G55E?@3 !"$&"*9B&."(+&#(D)$#1)$1"*&9()A(&0%19.#(*&"/&!"#$%& '"#()*&.(/(0$"#&;"7(*&A69*(#),9(&1*&+"01($B&.6(&$"& $%(1#&+$)$(9(++*(++8&,6$&$%(&;"7(*&$%(7+(9A(+&/)0(& +(#1"6+&0"*+(€6(*0(+&1/&$%(B&)#(&#(D)$#1)$(.?&y/&!"#$%& '"#()Z+&*1*($((*&D#1+"*&0)7D+&^SS32+5)%2Y_8&7"+$& ?,,&-&:1.:)1,():&H(,)1.,%&L,'2%.1,#&5.1+&1+,&?,<(,1)(39,0,(F ):8&\deiap&!cieldk8&%$$D+o{{$#()$1(+?6*?"#-{D)-(+{%1+$"#10)91*/"? )+DR†2%1*)?& xN &?,,$AQ$H(,)13$62#.,%$)0#$*+.0)8&]tm?&Jik?&ed&2nedc&^G53x_8& %$$Do{{;;;?%#10%1*)?"#-{(*{6*C$#()$BC,".1(+C)*.C0%1*)?& x4& ?,,&'17&v&w)#:8&%&'()$*"$(&x8&)$&I„&J67)&>)*C .)9&v&=7)*.)&ƒ#)B8&U&1$28$1+,$?+)#25%G$H+,$H(,)1F /,01$28$?1)1,:,%%0,%%&\0#,(&"01,(0)1.20):&4)58&2ncincm& ]ltka&^y0$?&G53@_8&38&%$$D+o{{;;;?0%)$%)7%"6+(?"#-{+1$(+{ .(/)69${X9(+{X(9.{X(9._."067(*${G53@35G4Q$)$(9(++*(++>)*C .)9ƒ#)B?D./? @5& ?,,&L,0.,#&?1)1&%D&L,0.,#&T#&<)1.208&%&'()$*"$(&x38&)$&3K? @3 &?,,$.#!&)$&33? xK& "9?&G@ O++6(&G "/&$%(&#(D)$#1)$(.&.(/(0$"#+&)#(&.($)1*(.&1*&V,20>,2(.$ =32+5)%2&)*.&9),<+,20$=32+5)%2?@G&=&;1$*(++& .($)1*(.&)$&9),<+20$=32+5)%2&/#"7&G53x&$"&G53@& +$)$(.&D#1+"*(#+&S"|(*Y&.1(.&.6(&$"&;():&%()9$%?@x&=& ;1$*(++&;%"&;)+&.($)1*(.&/#"7&G53@&$"&G53E&+$)$(.& D#1+"*(#+&;"#:(.&3@&%"6#+&)&.)B8&)*.&$%"+(&;%"& 0"69.&*"$&7(($&$%(&.)19B&;"#:&€6"$)&;(#(&+(A(#(9B& ,()$(*&)*.&*"$&)99";(.&$"&+9((D?@@&=*"$%(#&;1$*(++& .($)1*(.&1*&G53I&$(+$1X(.&$%)$&$%(&-6)#.+&#"6$1*(9B& $#)7D9(.&D#1+"*(#+&;1$%&+%"(+&)*.&%1$&1*7)$(+&;1$%& %)*.+&"#&X+$+8&)*.&.(*1(.&1*7)$(+&)00(++&$"&7()9+& "#&:(D$&$%(7&);):(&)+&D6*1+%7(*$?@E& 1$*(++(+&)9+"& $(+$1X(.&"/&;"7(*&;%"&)#(&#(D)$#1)$(.&;%19(&D#(-*)*$& ;1$%&$%(&,),B&"/&2%1*(+(&7(*&)#(&/"#0(.&$"&6*.(#-"& ),"#$1"*??@I&`(7)9(&.(/(0$"#+&%)A(&$(+$1X(.&$%)$&$%(& +(A(#1$B&"/&D6*1+%7(*$&"*&/"#01,9B&#(D)$#1)$(.&;"7(*& %)+&1*0#()+(.&6*.(#&'17&~"*-&\*Z+&#(-17(?@K& B#!/%.C2!D'&@0&( <%(&\!&)*.&1$+&)-(*01(+&)#(&)9#().B&6#-1*-&2%1*)&$"& +$"D&#(D)$#1)$1*-&!"#$%&'"#()*&.(/(0$"#+&D6#+6)*$& $"&$%(&34E@&2"*A(*$1"*&)*.&$%(&2=<8&,6$&2%1*)&%)+& *"$&,((*&#(+D"*+1A(?@N&&2%1*)Z+&+6DD"#$&/"#&!"#$%& '"#()&7)B&,(&#""$(.&1*&2%1*)Z+&1*$(#(+$&1*&%)A1*-&)& +$),9(&'"#()*&D(*1*+69)&"*&1$+&*"#$%(#*&,"#.(#&)*.&$"& %)A(&)&,6(#&/#"7&$%(&.(7"0#)$10&Q"6$%&'"#()?@4&<"& 0"6*$(#,)9)*0(&2%1*)Z+&+1-*1X0)*$&*)$1"*)9&+(06#1$B& &'B6*-C":&L"&($&)9?8&W+.1,$;)',($20$O&/)0$E.>+1%$.0$Q2(1+$ =2(,)$XYXYG$=2(,)0$"0%1.1&1,$82($Q)1.20):$A0.Z<)1.20&44? @x &"#!$)$&335? @@& "#!$)$&3GE? @E &"#!&)$&35N? @I &"#!&)$&@G3? @K &"#!&)$&@G5?& @N &?,,$2"*A(*$1"*&J(9)$1*-&$"&$%(&Q$)$6+&"/&J(/6-((+8&2',0,#$ 82($%.>0)1&(,&~69B&GN8&34E38&3N4&\?!?<?Q?&3xK8!3KIE!J",(#$)& 2"%(*8&*+.0)P%$M2(<,#$E,')1(.)1.20$28$Q2(1+$=2(,)0$E,8F &>,,%$"0<&(%$A0.1,#$Q)1.20%$*,0%&(,8&Ffllgedsk&Odki?8&3& ^~69?&G53@_8&%$$Do{{;;;?,#"":1*-+?(.6{~{7(.1){#(+()#0%{ X9(+{"D1*1"*+{G53@{5K{*"#$%C:"#()C%67)*C#1-%$+C0"%(*{ *"#$%C:"#()C6*C0"%(*?D./?„$P((&}("*&2%("98&AQ$A(>,%$*+.F 0)$12$?12'$E,')1(.)1.20$28$Q2(1+$=2(,)0$L,8,<12(%8&y=& !a‡k&^L(0?&3E8&G53E8&xo53&w>_8&%$$Do{{;;;?A")*(;+? 0"7{){6*1$(.C*)$1"*+C0%1*)C#(D)$#1)$1"*C*"#$%C:"#()C.(C /(0$"#+{x35@GE4?%$79„&'(**($%&J"$%8&E,#$O)0#,#G$*+.0)$ .%$):%2$*2/':.<.1$.0$Q2(1+$=2(,)P%!*(./,%!C>).0%1!O&/)0.F 138!]tm?!Jik?! cijn8!^`(,?!348!G53@8!3Go53!=>_8!%$$D+o{{;;;? %#;?"#-{*(;+{G53@{5G{34{#(.C%)*.(.C0%1*)C)9+"C0"7D910C 1$C*"#$%C:"#()+C0#17(+C)-)1*+$C%67)*1$B? @4 &&?,,$=9,(#$8&%&'()&*"$(&GE? @G