176
3
McGee
Qualitative Evaluation - Benefits & Identity
From a qualitative perspective, the impacts of naturalization upon the enjoyment of ‘the practical benefits of citizenship’ will be examined in the following
section.19 The fact that 94 percent reportedly applied to take citizenship shows
that it is considered as an attractive and/or beneficial prospect for most ajnabi
Kurds. Indeed, in interviews it was often mentioned that people were prepared
to pay large bribes in order to secure or expedite their and their family’s
naturalization.
I.D. cards for naturalised Kurds appear, and function, like those of all other
citizens of the Syrian Arab Republic. Though not always easy and sometimes
requiring bribes, interviewees reported being able to register property in their
names. A case that demonstrates the radically new opportunities for some
involves an individual being able to regularise a job that he had been doing
illegally for almost four years.20 Critically given the conflict situation, citizenship has provided its beneficiaries greater security to move freely around the
streets without the same level of risk of imprisonment/victimization if stopped
by police without valid papers.21
However, respondents also reported that in many ways acquisition of citizenship does not end the suffering they have experienced for decades. ‘For the
young,’ says one interviewee, ‘maybe they can seize the new opportunities, yet
for those of us who are older, we have internalised the position of inferiority.’22
In addition to this, many of the theoretically newly acquired rights remain limited or untestable due to the disruption of normalcy by Syria’s present conflict
situation. Public institutions are no longer operating ordinarily, but in many
19
20
21
22
Brad Blitz and Maureen Lynch, ‘Statelessness: The Global Problem, Relevant Literature and
Research Rationale’ in Brad Blizt and Maureen Lynch (eds), Statelessness and the Benefits of
Citizenship: A Comparative Study (Geneva Academy of International Humanitarian Law
and Human Rights, International Observatory on Statelessness, 2009) 4–17.
Newly naturalized citizens are not entitled to all the employment benefits of other
nationals since some public sector jobs require one to have been a citizen for 5 years.
In interviews, stateless Kurds often reported having problems with the police in Syria or
neighbouring countries, where checkpoints and police raids can be part of the daily reality. Anne Dekkar records the following example: ‘I am maktoum. This means my life is
worth nothing. If the police sees us talking I will have a big problem. But what can they
do? What can they take from me? I have nothing, I am a maktoum. My life can’t get
worse.”’ ‘Consequences of statelessness: Ajanib and Maktoum in Syria’ (MA thesis,
Amsterdam Free University 2011) 56.
Names of all respondents except public figures have been concealed in order to protect
their anonymity.
tilburg law review 19 (2014) 171-181