Laura Parker
IOM
different solutions. In a migratory context, to ensure adequate protection, the
need for the implementation of robust statelessness determination procedures
(SDPs) was recognised, but also the linking of such procedures to a suitable
protection status that should subsequently lead to the possibility of facilitated
naturalisation.
During the session ‘International protection and statelessness in a migration context – case studies and sticking
points’ the panellists delved in depth
into how migration and statelessness
so often coincide. Amongst other matters, they discussed the challenges
of the intersection of Refugee Status
Determination Procedures with Statelessness Determination Procedures
especially in the context of Greece; the
state of procedures in the UK and UK
Home Office criteria for granting permission for stateless persons to stay
and the position of stateless Palestinians from Syria seeking international
protection in the European Union. The
session ‘Born into irregularity, denied
nationality’ considered access to nationality specifically for children born to
migrant/refugee parents, where panellists discussed Colombia, the United
States, Thailand, and Hong Kong in
depth as well as holding a more general discussion.
Grand Challenge 3
Syria’s Statelessness
Landscape:
Eight Years On
Moderator:
Sabine Nolke
H.R., Ambassador of
Canada to the Netherlands
Panelists:
Fateh Azzam
Boston Consortium
for Arab Region Studies
Haqqi Bahram
Linkoping University
Martin Clutterbuck
Norwegian Refugee Council
Bernadette Habib
Frontiers Ruwad
Association
Thomas McGee
Peter McMullin Centre on
Statelessness / University of
Melbourne
18
“The Inter-American
Commission on Human
Rights is developing a
process to adopt the InterAmerican Principles on the
human rights of migrants,
refugees, and other persons
in the context of mixed
migratory movements...
these principles will reflect
existing international and
inter-American law and
standards developed by
UN and inter-American
bodies.”
Álvaro Botero
UN Committee
on Migrant Workers
It is impossible to talk about statelessness and displacement without reference
to the crisis in Syria. The 2011 revolution and the Syrian government’s extremely
violent retaliation caused a humanitarian disaster. 4.8 million refugees are
registered in neighbouring countries and over a million have travelled to Europe.
The majority hold Syrian nationality, facing no immediate risk of statelessness,
but a small proportion of the refugees are stateless. Others, particularly children
born in exile, are at risk of statelessness due to Syria’s nationality law, which is
gender discriminatory, or difficulties documenting their connection to Syria and
therefore their right to nationality. In Grand Challenge 3 ‘Syria’s Statelessness
Landscape: Eight Years On’ the panel looked at the risk of statelessness and
the additional vulnerability of displaced stateless refugees. The session was
introduced with an overview of the devastating humanitarian crisis in Syria.
The range of challenges faced by Syrian refugees in Jordan, Lebanon and Iraq
resulting from onerous state-specific bureaucratic procedures were illustrated,
highlighting that the role of bureaucracy not only causes problems for those
trying to access services, but can also perpetuate and reinforce other barriers
including, for example, gender discrimination.
The situation of minority groups, particularly, the Kurds in Syria, and in
displacement contexts were extensively considered. The practical challenges
experienced by forcibly displaced Kurds and Palestinians in Europe, including
widespread misidentification of statelessness, discrimination and obstacles to
resettlement and family reunification were explored. There was also a discussion
of what happens “post-statelessness” and how citizenship acquisition alone
cannot be assumed to solve all issues associated with statelessness.
“Syria is a microcosm of every dynamic that affects
citizenship and statelessness in the region and beyond.”
Fateh Azzam
Boston Consortium for Arab Region Studies & ISI Advisory Council