E MP LOYMENT
nationality she could not have her name put on the
title to the land. I feel really frightened that our home
could be taken at any time”.
JIRAIR,
19, GEORGIA
Vulnerability to exploitation and abuse
Statelessness can also exacerbate existing vulnerabilities, and in extreme cases, lead to exploitation and
abuse. In Côte d’Ivoire, many abandoned children are
stateless and their lack of documents proving their
identity and nationality makes their already precarious situation even more so. David (10) is not able to
go to school because his caregiver believes it would
not be possible without documents. His situation has
taken a serious toll on him; he is incontinent, and as
a result is made to sleep alone. While his friends and
foster siblings study, David takes the family’s sheep
out to pasture and does chores around the house.
Mistreatment can take different forms as stateless
children grow older. Clémentine (22) and Odile (21) are
stateless sisters living in Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire. When
they were very young they were made to work in a
restaurant and later forced into prostitution by the
aunt in whose care they had been placed as small
children. Lacking the protection of nationality documents they found themselves trapped. Only after the
situation became intolerable did they find the courage to flee. However, they lost all their belongings,
including the birth record of Clémentine’s four-year
old son, leaving him at a high risk of statelessness.
Kavita,
22, Malaysia.
“The doors of the world
are closed to me.”
The single most cited frustration of young peo-
©UNHCR / R. ARNOLD
Constant insecurity
Statelessness may also expose children to experiences that can make them feel insecure and frightened
to move around. In Malaysia, Sajna (19) recalls an incident when she was just 17 that has stuck with her:
“Two years ago I was on a bus which was stopped at a
roadblock. The police were looking for bandits. They
checked me and because I did not have any proof of
nationality they took me off the bus. It was so embarrassing; as if I was a criminal. I went to the police station and we finally settled the matter. It was a terrible
experience.”
Joseph (23) in Côte d’Ivoire explains how he fears
leaving his home village: “I can’t move around because
the police and gendarmerie ask for documents. I don’t
have documents so they ask me for money. Because
I can’t pay, they threaten to beat me and arrest me.”
Security was seen as integrally linked to citizenship.
One stateless parent from Italy, Dumitru, recalls how,
as an 18-year old, he had faced arrest and been threatened with deportation. Another stateless father, Sandokan, noted that Italian nationality was an especially
important form of protection in light of the fact that
his family was readily identifiable as Roma and thus
subject to discrimination.
In Thailand, Artee (18) explains that without citizenship, her family could, at any moment, be evicted
from their home: “My mother bought land informally
from someone she knew, but because none of us have
ple consulted for this report was the lack of jobs to
match their ability, ambitions and potential. Left unresolved, statelessness created new and insurmountable roadblocks for them as they were moving from
childhood to adolescence and adulthood. Whether
as a result of their limited access to educational opportunities or inability to travel as freely as their national counterparts, stateless youth often found that
statelessness held them back from freedom, independence and a break from the poverty and marginalization they had grown up with. Many revealed how
they had settled for a life that allowed them to meet
their basic needs, but fell far short of the future they
had imagined for themselves.
Uncertainty and disillusion
Most of the young people interviewed revealed that
as they approached school-leaving age they developed an acute sense of the impact that statelessness
would have on their future prospects. “My entire life is
a question-mark,” says Vikash (23) from Malaysia, summing up the frustration, uncertainty and disillusion
about the future articulated by many of the stateless
youth that UNHCR spoke to. He and others wanted
to travel to work in Singapore or India, but without
travel documents even a journey beyond the borders
of their federal state could land them in detention.
Javier (19) in the Dominican Republic, now a construction worker, has unfulfilled ambitions because
without documents proving that he is a national, he
has not been able to acquire the necessary academic
qualifications: “I want to study law because being a
18
S TAT E L E S S N E S S R E P O R T
lawyer is a profession that I respect” he says “My dream
is to practice law and help people with problems.”
Many of the stateless young people interviewed
said they had realized how severely their employment horizons were curtailed because of restrictions
on their travel to look for work beyond their local
communities and districts. As King (19) from Thailand
says: “To get a good job I need work experience. But
each time I want to travel beyond the district borders
I have to get a permit. It’s a real hassle and means that
I miss out on the experience I need to be competitive.
I watch others surge forward. Sometimes I feel like
this is the end.”
Through persistence and determination, some
stateless youth have made it to the end of demanding
and competitive selection procedures – only to be
refused employment because their lack of nationality
prevented them from meeting formal requirements
for the job.
Kavita in Malaysia wanted to teach art but no college would admit her because she was stateless. Undeterred, she applied for a job with the local nursery
school, but despite excelling during the interview she
was refused employment because she could not set up
a bank or pension account. Now, she works in a friend’s
grocery store. “It’s a dead-end job,” says Kavita. “But,
for now this job has been very helpful since I don’t
have proof of any nationality and can’t work anywhere
else. But I wish to become a teacher. It’s been my ambition since I was very young. I now tutor children at
my uncle’s house. It’s how I keep my dream alive.”
Unable to acquire professional qualifications, many
stateless young people pursue vocational courses
S TAT E L E S S N E S S R E P O R T
19