Preventing and Addressing Statelessness
121
Additionally, the Permanent Bureau of Hague Conference on Private
International Law (HCCH) has noted that: ‘While adoption may be a route for
an intending mother to acquire legal parentage in some States, this can be far
from straightforward since there may be rules which prohibit an adoption
being granted where the prospective adoptive parents took part in a procurement which is unlawful or contrary to public policy’.21
On the other hand, in States that expressly permit and regulate surrogacy,
the 2012 HCCH study highlights that some may allow for a ‘pre-approval’
process where the surrogacy arrangement must be presented and approved
before any agreement or medical treatment may proceed. In other permissive
State regimes, regulation takes the form of a set procedure for intending
parents to obtain legal parentage ex post facto. Legislation governing legal
parentage varies among States, as do procedures for transfer of parentage.
In reviewing existing practice in States that favour regulation, the HCCH
found that, while States may have varying requirements for the transfer of
legal parentage, the paramount consideration is placed on the best interests of
the child.22
3
Potential Measures to Address Statelessness in the Context
of International Commercial Surrogacy in the Long
and Short-Term
Possibilities for Multilateral Regulation and Harmonisation of
Private International Law
As international surrogacy arrangements are a form of private international
law, there have been calls for a new international convention to regulate such
matters. It is argued that such a private international law instrument would
provide more protection for surrogate mothers and also be in the best interests
of the child as it would prevent cases of statelessness. The HCCH Secretariat
has acknowledged that ‘this global phenomenon may ultimately demand a
global solution’.23 The Hague Adoption Convention24 has been suggested as
3.1
21
22
23
24
HCCH, ‘A Preliminary Report on the Issues arising from International Surrogacy
Arrangements’ (n 6) 10.
Ibid. 14.
Ibid. 30.
Hague Conference on Private International Law, Hague Convention on the Protection
of Children and Co-operation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption (29 May 1993)
(Hague Adoption Convention).
tilburg law review 19 (2014) 117-126