THIS CHAPTER LOOKS MORE CLOSELY
AT RIGHT TO NATIONALITY, DOCUMENTATION AND LEGAL STATUS, RIGHT TO
HEALTH, SOCIO-ECONOMIC RIGHTS
AND CIVIL AND POLITICAL RIGHTS,4 AND
MAKES THE FOLLOWING CALL TO ACTION
TO THE GOVERNMENT AND OTHER RELEVANT STAKEHOLDERS:
MALAYSIA
SUHAKAM, Children’s Commissioner,
Professor Dato’ Noor Aziah Mohd Awal
There are various groups who are stateless or
at risk of statelessness in Malaysia. In 2010, it
was estimated that 66,000 of a population of
2.6 million indigenous persons were stateless
or undocumented in Sarawak.5 Other groups at
risk include members of the Indian Tamil community in West Malaysia,6 and the Bajau Laut in
Sabah, East Malaysia: a traditionally maritime
migratory people.7 There are also many Rohingya refugees in Malaysia.8 Malaysian nationality
law is gender discriminatory: women, as a result of systemic and nationalised discrimination do not have equal rights to confer citizenship to their children and spouses. Children born
outside Malaysia to Malaysian mothers may
only acquire Malaysian citizenship at the discretion of the government by registering at a Malaysian Consulate or the National Registration
Department in Malaysia and applying via Article
15(2) – citizenship by registration – which is a
process fraught with delays, repeated rejections
without reasons and no guarantee of approval.9
Stateless people in Malaysia are more likely to
endure discrimination, marginalisation and
xenophobia as a result of their exclusion from
society, perpetuating their vulnerabilities and exacerbating the consequences of statelessness
in time of pandemic and in times of ‘normality’.
The stateless and those at risk of statelessness
were, prior to COVID-19, vulnerable to human
rights abuses. In the wake of COVID-19, these
vulnerabilities have been sharply exacerbated.
The lack of access to documentation and inability to acquire Malaysian legal identity has
heightened the precarity of stateless persons
and non-citizens, during the pandemic. Non-citizen spouses and children continue to face barriers to entering Malaysia due to border closures
and travel restrictions. Families with special
circumstances have also not been allowed into
resources, and those with family members with
physical and mental disabilities. It is anticipated
that there will be an increase in the number of
children of Malaysian women without access
to citizenship because of the inability of their
mothers to return to Malaysia to give birth.
Along with medical facilities being less accesor restricted services, making it much harder to
register births.
RIGHT TO NATIONALITY,
DOCUMENTATION AND LEGAL STATUS
As a result of an increase in COVID-19 cases,
the National Registration department switched
to only allowing e-payment (debit or credit card)
for registration, as opposed to cash payments.10
This is problematic as many stateless persons
do not have access to the internet or a bank account.
RIGHT TO HEALTH
Throughout the pandemic, healthcare services
have been largely inaccessible to stateless communities in Malaysia. Increased medical fees
and the risk of arrest faced by undocumented
migrants who seek treatment from government
11
At
the beginning of the pandemic, the Ministry of
Health claimed all persons, regardless of status
could and should seek testing and not fear arrest or detention, however, it subsequently failed
to protect those rounded up during raids by the
Ministry of Defence.12 Non-citizen spouses and
IMPLEMENT TEMPORARY SPECIAL MEASURES
TO ENSURE ALL CHILDREN HAVE EQUAL ACCESS
TO MALAYSIAN CITIZENSHIP WHEN BORN
OVERSEAS, PARTICULARLY IF TRAVEL TO
MALAYSIA AND MARRIAGE REGISTRATION WAS
NOT POSSIBLE DUE TO BORDER CLOSURES AS A
RESULT OF COVID-19.
ENSURE NON-CITIZEN SPOUSES AND CHILDREN
OF MALAYSIANS ARE NOT DENIED ENTRY TO
MALAYSIA, BEARING IN MIND THAT LONG-TERM
FAMILY SEPARATION IS NOT IN THE BEST INTEREST OF CHILDREN AND UNDERMINES THE RIGHT
TO FAMILY LIFE.
GUARANTEE EQUALITY AND NON-DISCRIMINATION IN COVID-19 VACCINATION SCHEMES,
TESTING AND TREATMENT TO NON-CITIZEN
SPOUSES AND CHILDREN OF MALAYSIANS,
MIGRANTS, REFUGEES, ASYLUM SEEKERS AND
STATELESS PEOPLE.
GRANT ALL NON-CITIZEN CHILDREN OF MALAYSIANS AS WELL AS STATELESS CHILDREN, ACCESS TO PUBLIC EDUCATION AND HEALTHCARE
FACILITIES ON AN EQUAL BASIS TO MALAYSIAN
CITIZENS.
accessing immigration services during the nadelays in booking appointments, sometimes for
many months and appointments being highly
competitive also faced these risks associated
with accessing healthcare, if their visas, passes or permits had expired as a result of these
delays.
LISTEN TO AND CONSULT GRASSROOTS COMMUNITIES AND NGOS TO FIND SUSTAINABLE
SOLUTIONS TO ADDRESS COVID-19 IMPACTS
ON STATELESS COMMUNITIES AND MALAYSIAN
BINATIONAL FAMILIES.
SOCIO-ECONOMIC RIGHTS
Exclusion from Emergency Relief: Stateless
persons and non-citizens have not been included
in government relief measures. However, some
faith groups and civil society organisations have
provided humanitarian aid to refugees, migrants
and stateless people. For the Bajau Laut community, for example, the lack of documentation
has meant exclusion from government relief
efforts. Government food baskets were only given to those with citizenship during the MCO in
April 2020 and October – December 2020. This
forced NGOs to step in, but navigating the MCO
order presented challenges, further complicated by an order from the government that only
allowed authorities to distribute aid. The MCO
33