ADVISORY COMMISSION ON RAKHINE STATE
National Verification (ICNV) – in June 2015. To obtain this card, applicants
were again required to register as “Bengali” in the application form. A year
later, the NLD Government restarted the process, issuing National Verification
Cards (a renaming of the ICNV), which no longer required applicants to
indicate their ethnicity or religion in the application form (although the
Commission has received complaints that ethnic references have still been
included on some occasions).
The sporadic implementation of the process – as well as the general lack
of communication, consultation and outreach from the Government – has
undermined public trust in the exercise within both communities. On the
Rakhine side, many fear that corrupt officials may allow a high number of
unqualified Muslims to obtain citizenship – a fear strengthened by alleged
reports of non-Kaman Muslims posing as Kamans in the verification process.
Some fear that the Government may eventually succumb to pressure from
the international community, which they see as biased in favour of Muslim
citizenship.
Muslims, on the other hand, object to the NVC as an interim step that will
subsequently qualify holders to apply for citizenship at some point in the
future. They are worried that this procedure follows a familiar pattern of
successive Myanmar governments issuing documents with a promise that
citizenship will follow, with the latter repeatedly failing to materialize. Many
are also reluctant to hand in their existing documents for fear of being left
undocumented. Others have lost their previous identification documents,
and are apprehensive that a process which is not based on bona fide will
simply be used against them. Trust is also undermined by the lack of tangible
benefits for those who successfully go through the process, as verified
Muslim citizens continue to face travel restrictions and other forms of
discrimination.
Recommendations:
In order to accelerate the verification process in line with the 1982 Citizenship
Law, the following steps should be taken:
11. The Government should immediately ensure that those who are
verified as citizens enjoy all benefits, rights and freedoms associated
with citizenship. This will not only serve to strengthen the Government’s
rule-of-law agenda, but also demonstrate immediate tangible
benefits of the verification exercise.
12. The Government should establish a clear strategy and timeline for
FINAL REPORT
27