‘I Must Be from Somewhere. I’m Not from the Moon’
participants were on this almost automatic pathway to citizenship, having been
granted permanent residence status as refugees. Deema described how the new
refugee label the SMA imposed on her would finally allow her to shed her prior
Palestinian refugee label:
Some people may say that: ‘Okay you’re not a refugee anymore, you’ve abandoned
Palestine’. But I remained a refugee for 63 years and I never saw anything from
Palestine. But after two years from this appointment [at the SMA] I can become
Swedish? The first trip I make the moment I get citizenship will be from [Sweden]
to Tel Aviv. 69
Acquiring citizenship in Sweden can be understood as a bureaucratic erasure
of former asylum/migration labels. However, while claiming that acquiring
citizenship would end their refugeeness, many participants did not perceive this as
also being an end to their Palestinianness/statelessness. As Mamdouh claimed:
Personally, I differentiate between my identity and my legal status. Legally, I’m
not a citizen of anywhere, legally I’m stateless — but I am Palestinian, this is my
identity. When I will soon get Swedish citizenship, I will legally be a Swedish
citizen but I’ll still be Palestinian. That will never change. 70
While Mamdouh will have a citizenship for the first time in his life and, thus,
not be stateless under Swedish or international law, citizenship for him and Deema
can be understood as what Elizabeth Mavroudi described as ‘pragmatic
citizenship’. 71 This concept, which resulted from Mavroudi’s research with
stateless Palestinians in Greece, identified that Greek citizenship was ‘sought,
acquired and negotiated for pragmatic and strategic reasons and can result in dual
or multiple feelings of belonging and attachment as well as de/reterritorialisation’. 72 Indeed, for Deema, the acquisition of Swedish citizenship was
not seen as her abandoning her Palestinian label, but rather as a practical step
towards being able to finally visit Palestine for the first time since she fled.
CONCLUSION
To shed light on the relationship between statelessness and refugeeness, this
research drew on the narratives of 22 PRS who fled from Syria to Sweden. It
focused on how they, as stateless refugees upon whom various labels are, were or
were not imposed, conceptualised the relationship between these labels over time
and space. It showed how these labels can be understood as being interconnected,
sequential, highly fluid and simultaneously restrictive. The relationship was also
shown to be situationally instructed and context dependent, though with spillover
from one context to another in some circumstances (largely related to their
Palestinianness or Syrian Palestinianness). This spillover sometimes led to the
participants’ exclusion from the privileges available to other refugees or stateless
persons, such as during their transit through Europe. At other times, labels were
hidden for pragmatic reasons; participants threw away documents stating that they
were PRS or deployed documents as a way of resisting the erasure of their
69
70
71
72
Interview with Deema, 71 years old from Yarmouk (Tom Rollins, 20 April 2017).
Interview with Mamdouh, 46 years old from Yarmouk (Jason Tucker, 10 February 2017).
Elizabeth Mavroudi, ‘Palestinians and Pragmatic Citizenship: Negotiating Relationships
between Citizenship and National Identity in Diaspora’ (2008) 39(1) Geoforum 307, 310.
ibid 310.
345