‘I Must Be from Somewhere. I’m Not from the Moon’
identity.’ 46 As Zak explained, ‘[w]e miss the camp: we miss Yarmouk and then
Syria’. 47
C
Leaving Syria
When the participants reflected upon their experiences of the labels, and how they
interacted with them, all noted a significant shift that began in Syria around 2011
to 2012. As Mamdouh described:
Previously we wouldn’t even say we are two countries — Palestinians and Syrians
were one. It’s only after the war that people started talking like this. And the Syrian
regime fostered this idea, that Palestinians and Syrians were separate. 48
The experiences of this socio-political, though not legal, separation differed for
the participants, but was generally reflected upon as a point of either confusion,
anger or a site of resistance to their Syrianness being withdrawn or contested. For
example, when trying to flee Syria, Zahra noted how she, for the first time, was
confronted with very restricted freedom of movement within what she perceived
as ‘her country’:
Why couldn’t I reach the northern areas of Syria legally? Why did I have to reach
it illegally? That’s because I’m Palestinian. That’s because I’m a Palestinian living
in Syria. Why should I be smuggled inside Syria, from one Syrian city to another
Syrian city? 49
For Zahra, this restricted freedom of movement, along with other factors, led
to her reconceptualising the relationship between her Palestinian and Syrian
identities. At this point she no longer considered herself as a ‘Palestinian-Syrian’
but, rather, a Palestinian who was living in Syria.
SYRIA’S NEIGHBOURING STATES AND THE WIDER REGION
A
Obscuring Their Palestinianness
Upon leaving Syria, the participants occupied a rather unusual position. Unlike
most other stateless refugee populations, they had to enter into a set of negotiations
over how their already existing, widely acknowledged and deeply politicised
stateless and refugee labels were to be recast, rejected or upheld by various actors.
In line with Roger Zetter’s claim about how the refugee label is imposed more
generally, 50 in Syria’s neighbouring states, and the wider region, this process was
reflected upon by the interviewees as being non-participatory.
There were, however, many examples of the rejection, resistance and obscuring
or deployment of these labels by the participants. Some detailed how they hid their
Palestinianness when dealing with bureaucracies or for pragmatic reasons when
trying to navigate everyday life. As Mohammed explained:
46
47
48
49
50
Elia Zureik, ‘Theoretical and Methodological Considerations for the Study of Palestinian
Society’ (2003) 23(1–2) Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and Middle East 152, 156.
Interview with Zak, 42 years old from Yarmouk (Tom Rollins, 22 April 2017).
Interview with Mamdouh, 46 years old from Yarmouk (Jason Tucker, 10 February 2017).
Interview with Zahra, 24 years old from Yarmouk (Tom Rollins, 29 April 2017).
Zetter, ‘Labelling Refugees’ (n 25).
339