3
STILL STATELESS,
STILL DETAINED
Many stateless persons in Europe have claimed asylum, sometimes simply because in the
absence of a statelessness determination procedure, this was the only option open to them to
try and regularise their stay. In the event of asylum being refused (whether rightly or wrongly),
many stateless persons are exposed to arbitrary long-term detention precisely because, lacking
a nationality, they most likely cannot be removed as no other state will accept them. In some
cases an individual’s statelessness will only become apparent following unsuccessful efforts by
a host state to re-document them during an attempted deportation process. Recent research
by UNHCR has revealed the long-term detention of stateless persons to be a problem in
several European countries (available at www.refworld.org/statelessness.html). The detrimental
impact on stateless persons - both before, during and after detention - can be severe and is
completely avoidable, as evidenced by these testimonies.
LUKA
Luka was born in Ukraine when it was still a part of the
former USSR. After growing up in an orphanage, he moved
to Slovakia in 1991 when he was only 15 years old. He has
never possessed any documents establishing a nationality. As
a result, since becoming an adult, Luka has been repeatedly
detained in Slovakia, including while police investigated
the possibility of removing him to Ukraine. However, such
attempts have proved fruitless because Ukraine refuses
to accept him as a national. On the last occasion Luka
was detained for 14 months in 2010. When ordering his
release the court found that his expulsion from Slovakia
was not possible and Luka was finally granted tolerated stay.
However, his problems are far from over. Despite having
lived in Slovakia for over 20 years, Luka is still not recognised
as being stateless and his tolerated stay status does not
allow him to work or to have health insurance. He cannot
marry his partner or be registered officially as the father of
his son. Recently his application to renew his tolerated stay
was refused due to his inability to submit new documents
from the Ukrainian embassy. He was subsequently fined for
his illegal stay. This cycle shows no sign of ending.
Provided by the Human Rights League, Slovakia