There is no accompanying regulation to this section of the
Citizenship Act. Thus, the above legislation must be viewed and
interpreted in light of the definition of 'stateless' in international law
and practice.
‘Does not have citizenship or nationality of another country’
Section 2(2) makes a distinction between (1) a child who ‘does not
have citizenship or nationality of another country’ and (2) a child
who ‘does not have the right to such citizenship or nationality.’ Thus
two different meanings must be intended.
The phrase ‘does not have the citizenship or nationality of any
country’ applies to several groups.
First, this provision refers to those who may qualify for citizenship
or nationality under the law of another country, but who are simply
not recognised by the state in question due to discrimination,
inability to prove their nationality or other reasons. They may have
the right to such citizenship, but nonetheless cannot access it.
Second, this provision includes those who have a potential claim
to or right to claim a foreign nationality, but must first submit an
application that must be approved before they are recognised as
nationals. UNHCR’s Concept of Stateless Persons under
International Law provides the guidance that:
... whether or not he is a national of a State under the operation of its
law requires an assessment of the viewpoint of that State.” Those “who
appear to be eligible for citizenship, but who must lodge an application
are generally not considered to be nationals ‘by operation of law,’ as the
acquisition of nationality it not automatic but rather, discretionary.”120
Until such an application is submitted and approved, such persons “do
not have” another citizenship or nationality, regardless of whether they
could qualify or have the right to make such an application.
Finding a solution for clients: immigration status and citizenship
Interpretation and application of section 2(2)
The inclusion of this phrase protects children's right to citizenship
from birth. Children need not wait for a discretionary application to
be processed or an administrative requirement to be fulfilled at
some future date because section 2(2) provides them with the right
to South African citizenship provided they were born on the
territory and do not have citizenship or nationality elsewhere.
120 UNHCR, The 1954 Convention relating to the status of Stateless Persons:
Implementation within the European Union Member States and Recommendations
for Harmonisation (October 2003), available at: http://www.unhcr.org/
refworld/docid/415c3cfb4.html.
Promoting citizenship and preventing statelessness in South Africa: A practitioner’s guide
85
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents