Statelessness as a Product of Slippery Statecraft
In line with the emphasis on innocence, the campaign has highlighted child
statelessness (actions 2 and 7). 84 A 2015 report entitled I am Here, I Belong: The
Urgent Need to End Child Statelessness conveys a sense of urgency — 'with a
stateless child being born somewhere in the world at least every 10 minutes, this
is a problem that is growing. In countries hosting the 20 largest stateless
populations, at least 70,000 stateless children are born each year’. 85 It goes on to
strategically link the issue to development goals, such as child vaccination, access
to medical care and education and youth access to employment. 86 The report
appeals to moral arguments about children missing out on the experience of being
a child, as well as the human right of every child to a nationality. 87 Again, UNHCR
insists that the problem is relatively easy to solve, preventable, straightforward,
since the causes are simply discrimination, gaps in nationality laws and lack of
birth registration. 88 UNHCR has partnered with the United Nations Children’s
Fund (‘UNICEF’) to promote universal birth registration; the two agencies
convene the global Coalition on Every Child’s Right to a Nationality, comprised
of international organisations, civil society organisations and legal clinics, which
aims to ‘develop, expand and strengthen international cooperation to raise
awareness about and combat the hidden problem of child statelessness’. 89
As for the link with international migration, UNHCR carefully avoids the
thorny issue of irregular migration and the risk of statelessness for children.
Campaign materials recognise that most stateless people remain in the country of
their birth, which can and does include children of people with precarious
citizenship, such as the temporary status forms described above. However, the
focus is quite narrow: campaign action 6 calls for granting protection status to the
relatively small number of stateless persons who have migrated and facilitating
their naturalisation. 90
The 2017 #IBELONG Campaign report focuses on discrimination against
minority groups. 91 It points out that discrimination and lack of documentation can
be both cause and consequence of statelessness: ‘Lack of such documentary proof
can result in a vicious circle, where authorities refuse to recognise an otherwise
valid claim to nationality’. 92 Recommended actions to remedy this situation, in
line with actions 1, 2, 4, 7 and 8 of the Global Action Plan, are technical in nature
(eg ensure universal birth registration; eliminate procedural and practical obstacles
to the issuance of nationality documentation). 93
Gender discrimination is framed in similarly technical terms (action 3). 94
UNHCR sees its role as advocate and provider of technical advice as to how to
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
Global Action Plan (n 69) 9, 18.
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, I am Here, I Belong: The Urgent Need to
End Child Statelessness (Report, November 2015) 1.
ibid 2.
ibid.
ibid.
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, ‘IBELONG: Coalition on Every Child’s
Right to a Nationality’ <http://www.unhcr.org/ibelong/unicef-unhcr-coalition-child-rightnationality/>.
Global Action Plan (n 69) 16.
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, ‘This is our Home’: Stateless Minorities
and Their Search for Citizenship (Report, November 2017).
ibid 2.
Global Action Plan (n 69) 7, 9, 13, 18, 21.
ibid 12.
147