European States’ Obligations to Repatriate the Children Detained in Camps in Northeast Syria
documents, return to their countries, or contest the arbitrary detention, inhuman
and degrading treatment, and other human rights violations they are being
subjected to.
Legal challenges are now being filed in various fora in response to the failure of
European governments to repatriate their child nationals together with their
primary caregivers. This legal briefing paper is intended to assist litigators and
other advocates in advancing creative approaches to address this seemingly
intractable problem. This paper seeks to provide an overview of the main
European and international legal standards that can be invoked by litigators and
advocates to argue for the proactive repatriation of the children detained in camps
in northeast Syria.
The paper employs, primarily, a child’s rights perspective and sets out the legal
arguments that can be invoked for the children’s repatriation, together with their
primary caregivers. The arguments put forward in this briefing paper start with
three overarching human rights considerations: the extraterritorial application of
European States’ human rights obligations in relation to the child nationals
detained in northeast Syria, the best interests of the child, and the right to be free
from discrimination. Following this, the briefing paper examines several key
substantive human rights arguments regarding: the right to nationality, the right to
access consular assistance, the right to enter one’s own country, the right to life,
the right to be free from torture and ill-treatment, the right to liberty and security,
and the right of child victims of armed conflict to reintegration and recovery.
In practice, respecting and fulfilling these rights may require States’ positive
actions in enabling the expeditious return of children. If it is strictly necessary and
done with appropriate safeguards, this can mean establishing nationality by
facilitating DNA tests to determine paternity or maternity; obtaining regular
assurances of the children’s physical and psychological health, as well as
providing appropriate medical care; issuing administrative documents, including
identity and travel documents, to enable children’s assisted travel to their country
of nationality; and contacting camp authorities, consular representatives located
nearby, and NGOs active on the ground to effectively carry out repatriation.
The need to protect the rights of children detained in camps in northeast Syria, the
briefing paper asserts, creates an obligation on European States to proactively
repatriate all their child nationals together with their primary caregivers.
5